HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016567.jpg

2.62 MB
View Original

Extraction Summary

8
People
6
Organizations
3
Locations
4
Events
3
Relationships
4
Quotes

Document Information

Type: Meeting minutes
File Size: 2.62 MB
Summary

This document contains minutes from a Palm Beach Code Enforcement Board meeting on July 17, 2008, primarily discussing environmental regulations regarding sea grape trimming during turtle nesting season at the Nightingale Beach Club Association. The Board debated enforcement timelines, referencing coordination with the DEP and FWC, while the violator's representative, Mr. Maxey, raised concerns about economic hardship and alleged the Town itself had violated similar regulations. The Board ultimately voted to grant an extension for compliance until November 7, 2008, with a potential daily fine of $250.00 thereafter.

People (8)

Name Role Context
Mr. Walton Town Official/Staff
Discussing enforcement and agreements with DEP/FWC regarding turtle nesting season.
Mr. Maxey Representative for Nightingale Beach Club/Violator
Arguing against the timeline for compliance and alleging unequal application of the law.
Mr. Ochstein Board Member
Questioning enforcement preclusion and making the final motion.
Mr. Wettstein DEP Official
Agreed to wait until the end of turtle season for enforcement.
Ms. Higgins FWC Official
Agreed to wait until the end of turtle season for enforcement.
Mr. Hoffman Board Member
Asked about permit issuance date; stated Board lacks authority to modify Code.
Mr. Balletine Board Member
Inquired about the 7-day compliance sufficiency.
Mr. Vanneck Board Member
Suggested more research is needed and that Town code may have gone too far.

Organizations (6)

Name Type Context
Code Enforcement Board
The body holding the meeting.
Nightingale Beach Club Association
The entity facing code compliance issues regarding sea grape trimming.
Town Council
Governing body mentioned regarding code modification.
DEP
Department of Environmental Protection.
FWC
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission.
NOAA
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.

Timeline (4 events)

2008-03-19
Permit application submitted by Mr. Maxey
N/A
2008-06-16
Permit issued
Nightingale Beach Club
2008-07-17
Code Enforcement Board Meeting
Palm Beach
Board Members Mr. Walton Mr. Maxey
2008-11-07
Deadline for compliance
Nightingale Beach Club

Locations (3)

Location Context
Location of street lights and the meeting.
Location of the sea grapes requiring trimming.
Mentioned in context of a $2,000,000 expenditure/dispute.

Relationships (3)

Mr. Walton Professional/Regulatory Mr. Wettstein
Mr. Walton spoke with Mr. Wettstein regarding enforcement timing.
Mr. Walton Professional/Regulatory Ms. Higgins
Mr. Walton spoke with Ms. Higgins regarding enforcement timing.
Mr. Maxey speaks on behalf of the club regarding the permit and compliance.

Key Quotes (4)

"spending $2,000,000 to fight Lake Worth on the other side."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016567.jpg
Quote #1
"Mr. Maxey said he is in consultation with an attorney to find out what measures he can take."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016567.jpg
Quote #2
"The Town did not apply for a permit to cut its own sea grapes and judging from the guidelines he has in his permit, the Town would be in violation of almost everyone of those guidelines."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016567.jpg
Quote #3
"MOTION BY MR. OCHSTEIN TO GRANT THE VIOLATOR UNTIL NOVEMBER 7, 2008 TO COME INTO COMPLIANCE"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016567.jpg
Quote #4

Discussion 0

Sign in to join the discussion

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document