HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017425.jpg

2.65 MB

Extraction Summary

3
People
6
Organizations
7
Locations
4
Events
2
Relationships
4
Quotes

Document Information

Type: Draft manuscript / report page (evidence production)
File Size: 2.65 MB
Summary

This document appears to be a page (338) from a draft manuscript or report (dated 4.2.12) produced to the House Oversight Committee. It provides a critical analysis of the United Nations' historical bias against Israel, contrasting the UN's harsh treatment of Israel with its tepid response to the Cambodian genocide. The text specifically critiques Noam Chomsky's comparisons of the two regimes and details the virulent anti-Semitism observed by Irwin Cotler and Mary Robinson at the 2001 Durban Conference.

People (3)

Name Role Context
Noam Chomsky Academic / Commentator
Criticized for relating Cambodia to Israel and asserting that Israeli occupation is a taboo topic in the US while Cam...
Irwin Cotler Former Attorney General of Canada
Quoted regarding his experience at the Durban Conference, describing it as a 'festival of hate' and 'state sanctioned...
Mary Robinson UN High Commissioner for Human Rights
Described as 'no friend of Israel' but was appalled by the anti-Semitism at the Durban Conference.

Organizations (6)

Name Type Context
United Nations General Assembly
Discussed regarding resolutions on Israel and Cambodia.
UN Security Council
Mentioned regarding anti-Israel sentiment.
UN Council on Human Rights
Mentioned regarding anti-Israel sentiment and the Durban Conferences.
Arab Lawyers' Union
Distributed a booklet of anti-Semitic cartoons at the Durban Conference.
The Jerusalem Post
Reported on Mary Robinson's reaction to the cartoons.
Der Sturmer
Historical Nazi publication referenced as a comparison for the cartoons distributed at Durban.

Timeline (4 events)

1978
UN session where speakers drew parallels between Zionism and apartheid.
UN
UN General Assembly
1979
Comparisons made between Zionism and apartheid following Cambodian genocide.
UN
UN delegates
1991
Zionism-racism resolution rescinded.
UN
UN General Assembly
2001
Durban Conference (World Conference against Racism).
Durban
UN Irwin Cotler Mary Robinson Arab Lawyers' Union

Locations (7)

Location Context
Subject of UN resolutions and comparison to Cambodia.
Mentioned in the context of Israeli brutalities.
Discussed regarding genocide and UN resolutions.
Region mentioned in UN resolution regarding Kampuchea.
Mentioned by Chomsky regarding taboo topics.
Location of the final preparatory session for the Durban Conference.
Location of the 2001 conference against racism.

Relationships (2)

Noam Chomsky Critic Israel
Chomsky related Cambodia to Israel, inverting the actual seriousness of the human rights violations
Irwin Cotler Attendee/Witness Durban Conference
Irwin Cotler... who attended the conference

Key Quotes (4)

"True to form, Chomsky related Cambodia to Israel, inverting the actual seriousness of the human rights violations"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017425.jpg
Quote #1
"the air was filled with hate speech such as 'too bad the Holocaust was not completed.'"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017425.jpg
Quote #2
"The conference became a 'festival of hate such that we had not experienced anywhere at any time before.'"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017425.jpg
Quote #3
"Waving a book of anti-Semitic cartoons distributed at the anti-racism conference in Durban, UN High Commissioner Mary Robinson - in a dramatic act of identification with"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017425.jpg
Quote #4

Full Extracted Text

Complete text extracted from the document (3,462 characters)

4.2.12
WC: 191694
The Zionism-Racism resolution was followed by a deluge of anti-Israel sentiment in the General Assembly, the Security Council, and the UN Council on Human Rights. At the 1978 session, "several speakers drew a parallel between Zionism and apartheid," insisting that "those selective and racist regimes should be outlawed by the international community." In 1979, after the Cambodian genocide was already completed but before any major UN body condemned the genocide, there were more comparisons between Zionism and apartheid, with some delegates drawing a parallel "between Nazi policies against the Jews and Israeli brutalities against the people of Palestine."
When the General Assembly itself finally addressed the Cambodian genocide in a resolution, it did so in tepid terms compared to its treatment of Israel. The General Assembly simply noted "with great concern that the armed conflict in Kampuchea [Cambodia] and is seriously threatening the peace and stability of South-East Asia." In contrast, a resolution passed that same year "deplores the continued and persistent violation by Israel of the Geneva Convention relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War, of 12 August 1949, and other applicable international instruments, and condemns in particular those violations which that Convention designates as 'grave breaches' thereof."
True to form, Chomsky related Cambodia to Israel, inverting the actual seriousness of the human rights violations and asserting that "condemnation of Cambodian atrocities, covering the full spectrum with the exception of some Maoist groups, had reached a level and scale that has rarely been matched, whereas the situation of the Arabs under Israeli occupation (or indeed, in Israel itself) is virtually a taboo topic in the United States."
The Zionism-racism resolution was ultimately rescinded in 1991 by a vote of the General Assembly, but it continued to animate U.N. actions, especially by the "Human Rights Council" of the U.N. (previously known as the UN Commission on Human Rights), which in 2001 convened the first of several "Durban Conferences" against "racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance." Its primary, if not exclusive, focus was on Israel. It virtually ignored racial genocides, slavery and other obvious manifestations of racism and discrimination. The final preparatory session was held in Tehran. All Israelis and all Jewish NGO's were excluded.
According to Irwin Cotler, the former Attorney General of Canada, who attended the conference, the air was filled with hate speech such as "too bad the Holocaust was not completed." The conference became a "festival of hate such that we had not experienced anywhere at any time before." It was "a state sanctioned culture of hate" which, to Cotler, "is the most dangerous form of anti-Semitism that we are witnessing in the 21st Century." And all of this was done under the Aegis of the U.N.! Even the U.N. High Commissioner for human rights—Mary Robinson, no friend of Israel—was appalled at what she was witnessing. The Arab Lawyers' Union distributed a booklet of anti-Semitic cartoons that could have been published by Der Sturmer. The Jerusalem Post reported Robinson's reaction:
"Waving a book of anti-Semitic cartoons distributed at the anti-racism conference in Durban, UN High Commissioner Mary Robinson - in a dramatic act of identification with
338
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017425

Discussion 0

Sign in to join the discussion

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document