HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019730.jpg

1.7 MB

Extraction Summary

5
People
8
Organizations
3
Locations
2
Events
2
Relationships
2
Quotes

Document Information

Type: Book page / congressional record submission
File Size: 1.7 MB
Summary

This document is page 242 from the book 'How America Lost Its Secrets' by Edward Jay Epstein (indicated by the filename prefix 'Epst_' and content). It details Edward Snowden's time in Hong Kong, his communications with journalists Barton Gellman and The Guardian, and the intelligence community's assessment (via Michael Morell) of Snowden's vulnerability to Russian and Chinese intelligence. The page was submitted as evidence to the House Oversight Committee.

People (5)

Name Role Context
Edward Snowden Subject / Former NSA Contractor
Discussed regarding his leaks, time in Hong Kong, and interactions with journalists.
Michael Morell Former Intelligence Official / Panel Reviewer
Quoted criticizing Snowden's understanding of Russian and Chinese capabilities.
President Obama President of the United States
Appointed the panel Morell served on.
Barton Gellman Journalist
Received an ultimatum from Snowden regarding publication in The Washington Post.
Editor of The Guardian Journalist/Editor
Communicated with Snowden after he was in Moscow.

Organizations (8)

Name Type Context
NSA
National Security Agency; Snowden's former employer.
NSA’s Threat Operations Center
Specific division where Snowden had access to operations against Russia.
CIA
Central Intelligence Agency; assessed Snowden's situation in Hong Kong.
The Guardian
News outlet Snowden communicated with.
The Washington Post
News outlet Snowden pressured to publish documents.
Russian intelligence service
Adversary service mentioned as a threat to Snowden's secrets.
Chinese cyber services
Adversary service mentioned as a threat to Snowden's secrets.
House Oversight Committee
Implied by the Bates stamp 'HOUSE_OVERSIGHT'.

Timeline (2 events)

May 24 (Year implied 2013)
Snowden emails ultimatum to Gellman regarding publication deadline.
Hong Kong (Snowden's location)
May 27 (Year implied 2013)
Target date Snowden wanted the story to break.
N/A

Locations (3)

Location Context
Where Snowden gave interviews and was ensconced.
Location of Snowden's mission to meet journalists and contact diplomats.
Target of NSA operations.

Relationships (2)

Edward Snowden Source/Journalist Barton Gellman
Snowden sent ultimatum email to Gellman regarding publication.
Michael Morell Appointee President Obama
Morell reviewed the case on a panel appointed by President Obama.

Key Quotes (2)

"Snowden thinks he is smart... but he was never in a position in his previous jobs to fully understand the immense capabilities of our Russian and Chinese counterparts."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019730.jpg
Quote #1
"The purpose of my [Hong Kong] mission was to get the information to journalists"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019730.jpg
Quote #2

Full Extracted Text

Complete text extracted from the document (2,487 characters)

242 | HOW AMERICA LOST ITS SECRETS
any interview that he ever gave in Moscow under Russian protection, but he had similar access to NSA operations against Russia in his job at the NSA’s Threat Operations Center.
The enormous power of the NSA rested in its ability to keep its sources and methods secret from its foes. A queen on the chessboard could be captured by a lowly pawn if it was well-placed. In this case, the person who had it in his power to expose the NSA’s critical sources and methods would no doubt be considered fair game by America’s adversaries, including the Chinese and Russian cyber services. Indeed, how could they resist such a prize?
Snowden might have believed that he was in control, but the CIA believed that confidence was misinformed. “Snowden thinks he is smart,” Morell said, after reviewing the case on a panel appointed by President Obama, “but he was never in a position in his previous jobs to fully understand the immense capabilities of our Russian and Chinese counterparts.” He could adopt a cocky tone in his postmortem conversations with journalists in Moscow, but in truth he had no means to block the efforts of the Chinese or Russian services in Hong Kong. Even before Snowden contacted its diplomats in Hong Kong, the Russian intelligence service would swing into action to determine his intelligence value.
How many days he planned to be in Hong Kong depended on how speedily he could arrange a meeting with journalists. “The purpose of my [Hong Kong] mission was to get the information to journalists,” he told the editor of The Guardian after he was safely ensconced in Moscow. He indicates that he was working under a tight clock. The time pressure resulted in his e-mailing an ultimatum to Gellman on May 24: either Gellman would publish the selected documents in The Washington Post within seventy-two hours, or he would lose the exclusive scoop. Snowden wanted the story to break on May 27, without his true identity (which Gellman did not know) attached to it. His identity would be known to a foreign mission in Hong Kong if Gellman acceded to his demands, because, as previously mentioned, Gellman’s story would enclose an encoded signal he planned to use as proof of his bona fides. So even before the Guardian reporters had agreed to come to Hong Kong, Snowden had plans to deal with a foreign mission. If the Post had accepted his terms, Snowden would
Epst_9780451494566_2p_all_r1.indd 242 9/30/16 8:13 AM
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019730

Discussion 0

Sign in to join the discussion

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document