HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016630.jpg

1.89 MB

Extraction Summary

9
People
3
Organizations
3
Locations
2
Events
2
Relationships
4
Quotes

Document Information

Type: Meeting minutes (code enforcement board)
File Size: 1.89 MB
Summary

Minutes from a Code Enforcement Board meeting on July 17, 2008, documenting a hearing regarding the Nightingale Trail Beach Club Association. The Board voted 6-1 to grant the association until November 7, 2008, to cut sea grapes (after turtle season) or face a $250 daily fine. Mr. Maxey represented the association, discussing its informal nature, finances ($75 annual dues), and membership.

People (9)

Name Role Context
Mr. Vanneck Board Member
Asked for clarification on motion; Voted NO on the motion.
Mr. Walton Staff/Official
Advised on the details of the motion and who the fine applies to.
Mr. Fried Board Member
Asked questions about the legal status of the association; Voted YES; Advised Mr. Maxey.
Mr. Maxey President, Nightingale Trail Beach Club Association
Representing the association (the violator); answered questions about membership and finances.
Ms. Van Buren Board Member
Asked about property owner membership and finances; Voted YES.
Mr. Ochstein Board Member
Made the motion to grant time for compliance; Voted YES.
Mr. Ballentine Board Member
Seconded the motion; Voted YES.
Ms. Greenberg Board Member
Voted YES.
Mr. Hoffman Board Member
Voted YES.

Timeline (2 events)

2008-07-17
Code Enforcement Board Meeting regarding Nightingale Trail Beach Club Association violation.
Palm Beach (implied by context of names/street names)
2008-11-07
Deadline for sea grapes to be cut to achieve compliance.
Nightingale Trail

Locations (3)

Relationships (2)

Mr. Maxey President/Representative Nightingale Trail Beach Club Association
Mr. Maxey said he was president and that he keeps the books
Mr. Ochstein Board Colleagues Mr. Ballentine
Motion by Mr. Ochstein... Seconded by Mr. Ballentine

Key Quotes (4)

"the motion was that the sea grapes must be cut after turtle season, by November 7, 2008"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016630.jpg
Quote #1
"Mr. Maxey said it was an informal body, that on the deeds, everyone owns this piece of property in common."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016630.jpg
Quote #2
"MOTION BY MR. OCHSTEIN TO GRANT THE VIOLATOR UNTIL NOVEMBER 7, 2008 TO COME INTO COMPLIANCE"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016630.jpg
Quote #3
"MOTION PASSES 6-1"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016630.jpg
Quote #4

Full Extracted Text

Complete text extracted from the document (2,198 characters)

Code Enforcement Board Meeting Minutes 07/17/08
Mr. Vanneck asked for clarification on what the motion was and Mr. Walton advised the motion was that the sea grapes must be cut after turtle season, by November 7, 2008 and if they were not cut by that date, a $250.00 a day fine would commence on November 8, 2008 and continue until compliance was achieved.
Mr. Fried asked who the fine would apply to and Mr. Walton said it would be to the Nightingale Trail Beach Club Association. Mr. Fried asked if this was a legally constituted body and Mr. Maxey said it was an informal body, that on the deeds, everyone owns this piece of property in common. There was some additional discussion on the ordinance. Ms. Van Buren asked if every single property owner on the street was a member of the association and Mr. Maxey said every property owner on Nightingale Trail was and there were one or two houses on North Ocean and North Lake as well. Mr. Maxey said there were 23 separate memberships. Ms. Van Buren asked about the finances and Mr. Maxey said there were annual dues of $75.00 a year and a common bank account of $3500 or $3600. Mr. Maxey said that if a fine was incurred, that is probably where the money would come from but he did not believe, because of his fiduciary responsibility to the group, he could fight the decision with any of those monies. Mr. Ochstein asked if he was an elected officer and Mr. Maxey said he was president and that he keeps the books and makes sure the place is in good condition.
MOTION BY MR. OCHSTEIN TO GRANT THE VIOLATOR UNTIL NOVEMBER 7, 2008 TO COME INTO COMPLIANCE AND IF COMPLIANCE IS NOT ACHIEVED BY THAT DATE, TO ASSESS A FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF $250.00 A DAY UNTIL COMPLIANCE IS ACHIEVED
SECONDED BY MR. BALLENTINE
MOTION OPPOSED
ROLL CALL VOTE:
MR. OCHSTEIN YES
MR. BALLENTINE YES
MR. FRIED YES
MS. GREENBERG YES
MS. VAN BUREN YES
MR. VANNECK NO
MR. HOFFMAN YES
MOTION PASSES 6-1
Mr. Fried advised Mr. Maxey that the Code Enforcement Board’s position was to enforce the Code and said that he had always found the Town Council members to be very receptive, individually and as a group. Mr. Fried said it was not beyond
15
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016630

Discussion 0

Sign in to join the discussion

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document