HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017354.jpg

2.26 MB

Extraction Summary

7
People
4
Organizations
4
Locations
3
Events
2
Relationships
5
Quotes

Document Information

Type: Book draft / manuscript excerpt (evidence exhibit)
File Size: 2.26 MB
Summary

The document is a manuscript draft (dated 4.2.12) likely written by Alan Dershowitz, describing his personal friendship and advisory relationship with President Bill Clinton. It details their social interactions in Martha's Vineyard, Dershowitz's failed lobbying for the release of Jonathan Pollard, and his critical analysis of Clinton's handling of the Monica Lewinsky scandal. The text appears to be an exhibit from a House Oversight Committee investigation.

People (7)

Name Role Context
Alan Dershowitz Narrator / Author
The 'I' in the text; implied by the context of legal advice, Jewish advocacy, Martha's Vineyard connection to Clinton...
Bill Clinton President of the United States
Subject of the narrator's advice, neighbor in Martha's Vineyard, friend.
Jonathan Pollard Prisoner
Subject of a clemency request by the narrator to President Clinton.
Monica Lewinsky White House Intern
Described as having a 'surreptitious sexual relationship' with the President; referred to as a 'young blabbermouth'.
Kenneth Starr Prosecutor
Described as 'somewhat puritanical'; investigating the President.
Hillary Clinton First Lady
Mentioned regarding the 'right wing conspiracy' allegation.
George Washington Former President
Historical reference regarding a letter to Jews of Newport.

Organizations (4)

Name Type Context
White House
Location of meetings and events.
Intelligence Community
Opposed the commutation of Jonathan Pollard's sentence.
US Senate
Reference to 'several Jewish senators' who opposed Pollard's commutation.
House Oversight Committee
Source of the document (indicated by footer stamp).

Timeline (3 events)

1990s
Clinton attending Jewish Service
Unknown (likely Martha's Vineyard)
1990s
Monica Lewinsky Scandal
White House
Various Summers (1990s)
Socializing in Martha's Vineyard
Martha's Vineyard
Bill Clinton Hillary Clinton Narrator (Dershowitz)

Locations (4)

Location Context
Vacation location where the narrator and the Clintons lived near each other.
Location where the narrator was invited and where the Lewinsky affair occurred.
Historical reference location.
Specific location of the sexual encounter mentioned.

Relationships (2)

Narrator (Dershowitz) Friend/Advisor Bill Clinton
We frequently dined, partied... became their friends... President sought my advice from time to time.
Bill Clinton Sexual Affair Monica Lewinsky
surreptitious sexual relationship with a White House intern

Key Quotes (5)

"mere 'toleration' is not good enough in America."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017354.jpg
Quote #1
"We frequently dined, partied and even square danced with them and became their friends."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017354.jpg
Quote #2
"You can choose not to listen, but I’m not going to stay quiet."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017354.jpg
Quote #3
"foolhardy decision to engage in a surreptitious sexual relationship with a White House intern"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017354.jpg
Quote #4
"reckless than oval office sex with a young blabbermouth whose goal was probably as much to brag about"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017354.jpg
Quote #5

Full Extracted Text

Complete text extracted from the document (2,953 characters)

4.2.12
WC: 191694
I concluded my article with the following words:
President Clinton’s visit was entirely in keeping with President George Washington’s letter to the Jews of Newport, Rhode Island, in which he wrote that mere “toleration” is not good enough in America. Here, Jews as well as others, must be treated as equals. The attendance of our president and first lady at a Jewish service made many Jews feel like first-class citizens, rather than tolerated guests.
I sent the President a copy of my article. He sent back a handwritten note expressing his appreciation for being invited to the services and for the article, and included a signed photograph of the dinner.
During the subsequent summers, the Clintons vacationed in Martha’s Vineyard and lived right near us. We frequently dined, partied and even square danced with them and became their friends. We were invited to the White House on several occasions and the President sought my advice from time to time.
Sometimes, I offered unsolicited advice, such as when I repeatedly urged him to commute the life sentence of Jonathan Pollard to time served. I pestered him so much about Pollard that he finally told me he didn’t want to hear anything more about it. I replied, “You can choose not to listen, but I’m not going to stay quiet.” In the end, he wanted to commute the sentence, but he got pushback not only from the intelligence community but also from several Jewish senators. He told me that if I can’t even get the Jewish senators to support commutation, how could he justify it to the intelligence community, which was adamantly opposed to it.
Another issue on which I initially offered my unsolicited advice involved the Monica Lewinsky matter. As I watched the Lewinsky drama unfold, I saw a familiar pattern that had had gotten many other celebrities into trouble: opting for short term gratification without considering the longer term consequences.
At every decision point, the President and his advisors opted for a political tactic that helped them get good headlines and poll results in the short term, rather than focusing on the longer term strategy that might have prevented an entirely lawful sexual indiscretion from turning into a possible crime.
The first – and most important – point was the President’s foolhardy decision to engage in a surreptitious sexual relationship with a White House intern at a time when he knew he was under intense investigation by Kenneth Starr, a somewhat puritanical prosecutor and was subject to a lawsuit for sexual harassment by a vindictive woman who was represented by politically motivated lawyers.
If there was indeed a “right wing conspiracy” out there waiting to “get” the President, as Hillary Clinton had alleged in a television interview, it is difficult to imagine any action more reckless than oval office sex with a young blabbermouth whose goal was probably as much to brag about
267
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017354

Discussion 0

Sign in to join the discussion

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document