DOJ-OGR-00014508.jpg
630 KB
Extraction Summary
5
People
2
Organizations
0
Locations
3
Events
3
Relationships
2
Quotes
Document Information
Type:
Legal document
File Size:
630 KB
Summary
This document is a transcript of a legal summation by Ms. Menninger, who is analyzing the testimony of a witness named Jane. Menninger questions Jane's credibility regarding allegations of 'sexual massages' with women named Sophie and Eva, suggesting Jane may have invented the names. However, Menninger then introduces a flight log from November 1996 showing Jane, Sophie, and Eva (identified as Dr. Eva Dubin) on a flight together, using this evidence to re-contextualize their relationship and challenge Jane's narrative.
People (5)
| Name | Role | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Ms. Menninger | Speaker (likely attorney) |
Delivering the summation presented in the text.
|
| Jane | Witness/Accuser |
A person who told the government about Sophie and Eva, claiming they participated in 'sexual massages'. Her credibili...
|
| Sophie | Alleged participant in massages / Professional masseuse |
Described by Jane as 'blond and pretty' and married to a racecar driver. A flight log shows her on a flight with Jane...
|
| Eva | Alleged participant in massages |
A woman Jane claimed joined in massages with her and Sophie. She is later identified as Dr. Eva Dubin.
|
| Dr. Eva Dubin | Witness |
Identified as the 'Eva' from Jane's story and the flight log. She testified on the stand, was on the flight with her ...
|
Organizations (2)
| Name | Type | Context |
|---|---|---|
| SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. | Company |
The court reporting agency listed at the bottom of the document.
|
| government | Government agency |
The entity that Jane reported her allegations to.
|
Timeline (3 events)
Relationships (3)
Jane alleged they participated in 'sexual massages'. A flight log from November 1996 confirms they were on a flight together.
Jane alleged they participated in 'sexual massages'. A flight log from November 1996 confirms they were on a flight together.
They were on a flight together in November 1996. Eva testified that she knew Sophie and that Sophie was a 'professional masseuse'.
Key Quotes (2)
"Sure enough, on her very first flight log entry that has her name on it from November of 1996, she's on a flight with Sophie and Eva."Source
— Ms. Menninger
(Presenting evidence from a flight log that corroborates Jane's claim of knowing Sophie and Eva, despite questioning how Jane would have known their names.)
DOJ-OGR-00014508.jpg
Quote #1
"Sophie was a professional masseuse."Source
— Ms. Menninger (summarizing Eva's testimony)
(Providing an alternative explanation for the relationship between Eva and Sophie, countering Jane's allegation of a 'sexualized massage'.)
DOJ-OGR-00014508.jpg
Quote #2
Full Extracted Text
Complete text extracted from the document (1,610 characters)
Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 767 Filed 08/10/22 Page 108 of 257 2942
LCKCmax5
Summation - Ms. Menninger
LCKCmax5
Summation - Ms. Menninger
1 back in the '90s, can we talk about that. No. No, they didn't
2 do that.
3 Jane told about a woman named Sophie. She gave a
4 description. She was blond and pretty. She said Sophie
5 married a racecar driver and Sophie joined in these sexual
6 massages.
7 And then she told the government about a woman named
8 Eva, correct, she did not use a last name, but Eva. And this
9 wasn't just some disconnected Eva that showed up in an address
10 book from some unknown time in the future, jane said that Eva
11 joined in with Sophie. She joined in with Sophie. Those were
12 your words, yes, Eva joined in with Sophie.
13 So where would Jane have gotten these names, Sophie
14 and Eva, if the massage didn't really happen and she was trying
15 to come up with some names? Well, let's look. Sure enough, on
16 her very first flight log entry that has her name on it from
17 November of 1996, she's on a flight with Sophie and Eva. What
18 are the odds that the very first flight she takes is with two
19 women who she claims are on a group sexualized massage?
20 Let's look at Eva. Eva is flying with her child and
21 her nanny. She told you on the stand that she just had a baby.
22 Do you think that Dr. Eva Dubin that you just saw on the stand
23 with a child and a nanny who's on a flight with Sophie, she
24 joined in with Sophie was in a group sexualized massage. Eva
25 told you she knows Sophie. Sophie was a professional masseuse.
2 do that.
3 Jane told about a woman named Sophie. She gave a
4 description. She was blond and pretty. She said Sophie
5 married a racecar driver and Sophie joined in these sexual
6 massages.
7 And then she told the government about a woman named
8 Eva, correct, she did not use a last name, but Eva. And this
9 wasn't just some disconnected Eva that showed up in an address
10 book from some unknown time in the future, jane said that Eva
11 joined in with Sophie. She joined in with Sophie. Those were
12 your words, yes, Eva joined in with Sophie.
13 So where would Jane have gotten these names, Sophie
14 and Eva, if the massage didn't really happen and she was trying
15 to come up with some names? Well, let's look. Sure enough, on
16 her very first flight log entry that has her name on it from
17 November of 1996, she's on a flight with Sophie and Eva. What
18 are the odds that the very first flight she takes is with two
19 women who she claims are on a group sexualized massage?
20 Let's look at Eva. Eva is flying with her child and
21 her nanny. She told you on the stand that she just had a baby.
22 Do you think that Dr. Eva Dubin that you just saw on the stand
23 with a child and a nanny who's on a flight with Sophie, she
24 joined in with Sophie was in a group sexualized massage. Eva
25 told you she knows Sophie. Sophie was a professional masseuse.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
(212) 805-0300
(212) 805-0300
DOJ-OGR-00014508
Discussion 0
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document