HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031707.jpg

2.15 MB

Extraction Summary

8
People
3
Organizations
8
Locations
3
Events
2
Relationships
4
Quotes

Document Information

Type: Email (containing text of a political op-ed/article)
File Size: 2.15 MB
Summary

This document appears to be an email sent from an iPad containing the text of a political opinion piece (likely by Thomas Friedman, given the style and timeframe) criticizing Mitt Romney's 2012 visit to Israel. The text contrasts Romney's fundraising activities with Sheldon Adelson against his lack of engagement with Palestinian leadership, while praising the Obama administration's security support for Israel as confirmed by Ehud Barak. It concludes by urging US politicians to stop using the Israeli-Palestinian conflict for political gain. The document bears a House Oversight stamp.

People (8)

Name Role Context
Ehud Barak Defense Minister (Israel)
Quoted telling CNN about the Obama administration's support for Israeli security.
Barack Obama President of the United States
Praised by Barak for security cooperation; compared to Romney.
Mitt Romney US Presidential Candidate
Criticized for his behavior during a trip to Jerusalem, specifically regarding donors and Palestinians.
Adelson Donor
Sheldon Adelson (implied); mentioned as being at Romney's elbow during a fundraiser.
Mahmoud Abbas President of the Palestinian Authority
Romney did not meet with him in Ramallah.
Jimmy Carter Former US President
Cited as a statesman who told blunt truths to forge peace between Israel and Egypt.
Henry Kissinger Former Secretary of State
Cited as a statesman who built post-1973 disengagement agreements.
James Baker Former Secretary of State
Cited as a statesman who engineered the Madrid peace conference.

Organizations (3)

Name Type Context
CNN
Media outlet Ehud Barak spoke to.
Palestinian Authority
Government body based in Ramallah.
House Oversight Committee
Source of the document (implied by footer stamp).

Timeline (3 events)

Historical (1978)
Peace agreement between Israel and Egypt.
Camp David/Egypt/Israel
Jimmy Carter Israeli Leadership Egyptian Leadership
Historical (1991)
Madrid Peace Conference.
Madrid
July 2012 (implied)
Mitt Romney's fundraising breakfast in Jerusalem.
Jerusalem

Locations (8)

Location Context
Location of Romney's breakfast fundraiser.
Seat of the Palestinian Authority.
Subject of the political commentary.
Mentioned as being built by Palestinian business talent.
Used as a comparison for a potential future apartheid state.
Peace partner with Israel.
Involved in post-1973 disengagement agreements.
Location of a peace conference.

Relationships (2)

Mitt Romney Political/Financial Adelson
Adelson described as being at Romney's elbow during a $50,000-a-plate breakfast.
Ehud Barak Political/Diplomatic Barack Obama
Barak praises Obama's administration regarding Israeli security.

Key Quotes (4)

"I should tell you honestly that this administration under President Obama is doing in regard to our security more than anything that I can remember in the past."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031707.jpg
Quote #1
"While Romney had time for a $50,000-a-plate breakfast... he did not have two hours to go to Ramallah."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031707.jpg
Quote #2
"Romney didn’t know what he was talking about."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031707.jpg
Quote #3
"They both need the excuse at times that 'the Americans made me do it,' because their own politics are too knotted to move on their own."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031707.jpg
Quote #4

Full Extracted Text

Complete text extracted from the document (2,875 characters)

weaponry and intelligence — Defense Minister Ehud Barak told CNN on Monday, “I should tell you honestly that this administration under President Obama is doing in regard to our security more than anything that I can remember in the past.”
While Romney had time for a $50,000-a-plate breakfast with American Jewish donors in Jerusalem, with Adelson at his elbow, he did not have two hours to go to Ramallah, the seat of the Palestinian Authority, to meet with its president, Mahmoud Abbas, or to share publicly any ideas on how he would advance the peace process. He did have time, though, to point out to his Jewish hosts that Israelis are clearly more culturally entrepreneurial than Palestinians. Israel today is an amazing beehive of innovation — thanks, in part, to an influx of Russian brainpower, massive U.S. aid and smart policies. It’s something Jews should be proud of. But had Romney gone to Ramallah he would have seen a Palestinian beehive of entrepreneurship, too, albeit small, but not bad for a people living under occupation. Palestinian business talent also built the Persian Gulf states. In short, Romney didn’t know what he was talking about.
On peace, the Palestinians’ diplomacy has been a fractured mess, and I still don’t know if they can be a partner for a secure two-state deal with even the most liberal Israeli government. But I do know this: It is in Israel’s overwhelming interest to test, test and have the U.S. keep testing creative ideas for a two-state solution. That is what a real U.S. friend would promise to do. Otherwise, Israel could be doomed to become a kind of apartheid South Africa.
And here is what I also know: The three U.S. statesmen who have done the most to make Israel more secure and accepted in the region all told blunt truths to every Israeli or Arab leader: Jimmy Carter, who helped forge a lasting peace between Israel and Egypt; Henry Kissinger, who built the post-1973 war disengagement agreements with Syria, Israel and Egypt; and James Baker, who engineered the Madrid peace conference. All of them knew that to make progress in this region you have to get in the face of both sides. They both need the excuse at times that “the Americans made me do it,” because their own politics are too knotted to move on their own.
So how about all you U.S. politicians — Republicans and Democrats — stop feeding off this conflict for political gain. Stop using this conflict as a backdrop for campaign photo-ops and fund-raisers. Stop making things even worse by telling the most hard-line Israelis everything that they want to hear, just to grovel for Jewish votes and money, while blatantly ignoring the other side. There are real lives at stake out there. If you’re not going to do something constructive, stay away. They can make enough trouble for themselves on their own.
Sent from my iPad
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031707

Discussion 0

Sign in to join the discussion

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document