HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015870.jpg

1.61 MB

Extraction Summary

4
People
0
Organizations
1
Locations
2
Events
1
Relationships
3
Quotes

Document Information

Type: Book excerpt / evidence document (house oversight committee)
File Size: 1.61 MB
Summary

This document is a scanned page (180) from a book titled 'Are the Androids Dreaming Yet?', bearing the Bates stamp HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015870. The text describes the history of mathematics and physics, specifically discussing the concept of zero, Cantor's set theory regarding infinity, Poincaré's criticism of Cantor, Lord Kelvin's 1890 declaration on the state of science, and Einstein's 1905 papers. It appears to be part of a larger collection of documents reviewed by the House Oversight Committee, likely as evidentiary material.

People (4)

Name Role Context
Cantor Mathematician
Proposed that there are many infinities and developed set theory.
Poincaré Mathematician
Criticized Cantor's ideas, calling them a 'grave disease'.
Lord Kelvin Scientist
Announced in 1890 that mankind had discovered everything there was to know.
Albert Einstein Physicist
Studied physics in Berlin; published four papers in 1905 on Quantum Mechanics and Relativity.

Timeline (2 events)

1890
Lord Kelvin announced that mankind had discovered everything there was to know in science.
N/A
1905
Albert Einstein published four papers (two on Quantum Mechanics, two on Relativity).
Berlin (implied context of studies)

Locations (1)

Location Context

Relationships (1)

Poincaré Professional Critic Cantor
Poincaré ridiculed Cantor's set theory as a 'grave disease'.

Key Quotes (3)

"Poincaré wrote that Cantor’s ideas were a grave disease infecting the discipline of mathematics!"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015870.jpg
Quote #1
"Lord Kelvin announced in 1890 that mankind had discovered everything there was to know..."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015870.jpg
Quote #2
"Zero had been tamed. What about infinity?"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015870.jpg
Quote #3

Full Extracted Text

Complete text extracted from the document (2,556 characters)

180 Are the Androids Dreaming Yet?
the number zero behaves just like any other counting number. It also
works with multiplication. If I have zero lots of 4 cakes, I have no cakes.
Zero times four is zero, so multiplication with zero works. There is one
embarrassing exception, if I divide by zero I seem to get infinity. When I
was a child this was a definition for infinity, but nowadays mathematicians
simply forbid the operation. Division by zero is not allowed and if you
try it on your computer, you will get the not terribly useful, #DIV/0!
Error. That’s progress I guess!
Zero had been tamed. What about infinity?
Cantor showed that while you could think of infinity as a number,
it might not be just one number. He proposed there are many infinities.
In fact, there are a greater than infinite number of them! He did this
through a rigorous analysis of a new branch of mathematics called set
theory.
Set theory is now the cornerstone of modern mathematics, but it
was treated with suspicion in Cantor’s time. Rather than embrace the new
thinking, many mathematicians ridiculed it; Poincaré wrote that Cantor’s
ideas were a grave disease infecting the discipline of mathematics! This
seems odd given our modern propensity to embrace innovation, but the
tone of science back then was different: innovation was not necessarily
considered a good thing.
At the turn of the 20th century, scientists were on a mission to tidy
things up. Lord Kelvin announced in 1890 that mankind had discovered
everything there was to know and the role of future scientists was simply
to catalogue and observe the consequences of these laws, and to improve
the accuracy of measurement. The last thing scientists wanted was a
completely new set of numbers that behaved in strange ways. Cantor was
upsetting the apple cart, but he was in good company. Just a few miles
away in Berlin, a young Albert Einstein was beginning to study physics
in his spare time. Those studies would culminate in his four papers of
1905, two on Quantum Mechanics and two on Relativity, ushering in the
modern age of physics.
How to Count
To understand infinity you need to count in a particular way. You’re
probably used to counting with numbers. You count apples: one, two,
three, and say, “I have three apples.” You can do the same with oranges.
If you have three apples and three oranges, the totals are the same and
you can declare you have the same number of fruits. This is the first way
to count.
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015870

Discussion 0

Sign in to join the discussion

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document