HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029717.jpg

1.61 MB

Extraction Summary

1
People
2
Organizations
6
Locations
4
Events
2
Relationships
3
Quotes

Document Information

Type: Geopolitical analysis / report page (house oversight document)
File Size: 1.61 MB
Summary

This document page is a geopolitical analysis discussing how political and ideological priorities often outweigh economic rationality in nations like Pakistan and Iran. It specifically analyzes the shifting dynamics in the Middle East following the Arab uprisings, noting that Gulf monarchies are likely to become less supportive of US military operations because they view the US 'abandonment' of Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak as a shock. The document bears a House Oversight stamp.

People (1)

Name Role Context
Hosni [Mubarak] President of Egypt
Mentioned as having been 'abandoned' by the United States, which shocked Gulf monarchies.

Organizations (2)

Name Type Context
House Oversight Committee
Source of the document production (indicated by footer stamp).
Gulf Monarchies
Discussed regarding their changing relationship with the US military.

Timeline (4 events)

1970s
Pakistan pursues a nuclear weapons program.
Pakistan
2011 (implied)
Arab Uprisings / Arab Spring
Middle East
Arab States USA Europe
2011 (implied)
US 'abandonment' of Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak
Egypt
USA Hosni Mubarak Gulf Monarchies
Past (pre-document date)
Iraq Wars
Iraq
USA Arab States

Locations (6)

Location Context
Cited as an example of prioritizing political/ideological goals over economic rationality regarding nuclear weapons.
Compared to Pakistan regarding non-economic logic for policy decisions.
Region under analysis.
Mentioned in the context of past wars.
Discussed regarding foreign policy and military operations.
Mentioned regarding policymakers' views on Arab uprisings.

Relationships (2)

United States Diplomatic/Military Gulf Monarchies
Text states monarchies will likely be less accommodating to US military forces than in the past due to the handling of the Arab uprisings.
United States Political Abandonment Hosni Mubarak
Text mentions the US 'abandoned' President Hosni.

Key Quotes (3)

"political and ideological prerogatives trump economic rationality."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029717.jpg
Quote #1
"Arab states often loudly and publicly denounced "unilateral American" military action in the region at the same time as they supported it in backroom dealings"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029717.jpg
Quote #2
"The Gulf monarchies were shocked that the United States "abandoned" Egyptian President Hosni"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029717.jpg
Quote #3

Full Extracted Text

Complete text extracted from the document (1,284 characters)

politics: that time and again, political and
ideological prerogatives trump economic
rationality. It made little economic sense,
for example, for Pakistan to pursue a
nuclear weapons program in the 1970s,
just as it makes little economic sense for
Iran to do so today. Clearly, both
Pakistan and Iran made major policy
decisions based on political-military
priorities rather than economic
calculations.
As for the surviving monarchies in the
Middle East, they too will likely be less
accommodating to American military
forces than they have been in the past. To
be sure, much of the Arab support for
past American military operations -- like
both Iraq wars -- was hidden from the
public eye. Arab states often loudly and
publicly denounced "unilateral
American" military action in the region at
the same time as they supported it in
backroom dealings, quietly authorizing
facilities support and air, land, and sea
access.
But if Arab Gulf states were quietly
supportive in the past, their opposition to
American military force is likely to grow
in the future. They read the aftermath of
the Arab uprisings much differently than
did American and European
policymakers. The Gulf monarchies were
shocked that the United States
"abandoned" Egyptian President Hosni
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029717

Discussion 0

Sign in to join the discussion

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document