HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011799.jpg

2.39 MB

Extraction Summary

11
People
5
Organizations
4
Locations
2
Events
3
Relationships
3
Quotes

Document Information

Type: Book manuscript / memoir page (likely from ehud barak)
File Size: 2.39 MB
Summary

This document appears to be page 42 of a manuscript or memoir by former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak, found within House Oversight documents. The text details political turmoil during his premiership (circa 1999), specifically the loss of the United Torah Judaism party from his coalition due to a dispute over transporting heavy machinery on the Sabbath, and internal friction with minister Natan Sharansky. It mentions negotiations with Clinton and the pursuit of peace deals with Syria (Assad) and the Palestinians (Arafat).

People (11)

Name Role Context
Ehud Barak Narrator / Prime Minister of Israel
Author of the text, discussing his coalition government and peace negotiations.
Bill Clinton US President
Mentioned as someone the narrator went to see regarding negotiations.
Arik Sharon Politician (Opposition)
Presented a no-confidence motion in the Knesset.
Natan Sharansky Interior Minister
Threatened to vote against the government, eventually abstained.
Yitzhak Rabin Former Prime Minister
Mentioned regarding a historical government collapse in the 1970s.
Bibi (Benjamin Netanyahu) Former Prime Minister
Mentioned regarding previous procedures for transporting equipment on Shabbat.
Eli Suissa Shas Minister
Sided with United Torah Judaism regarding the Sabbath violation.
Haim Ramon Minister (Knesset Liaison)
Advised Barak to fire Sharansky.
Hafez al-Assad Syrian Leader
Mentioned in the context of potential peace agreements (referred to as 'Assad').
Yasser Arafat Palestinian Leader
Mentioned in the context of potential peace agreements.
Danny Yatom Appointee
Mentioned at the end of the page as someone Barak appointed (former role cut off).

Timeline (2 events)

Prior to September 1999
Transport of a huge steam-condensation machine (100 tons) from Haifa to Ashdod on Shabbat.
Haifa to Ashdod
September 1999
Loss of first coalition partner (United Torah Judaism) over Sabbath violation dispute.
Israel
Ehud Barak United Torah Judaism

Locations (4)

Location Context

Relationships (3)

Ehud Barak Political Adversaries Arik Sharon
Sharon presented a no-confidence motion against Barak.
Ehud Barak Political Ally/Adversary Natan Sharansky
Barak made him Interior Minister, but Sharansky threatened to vote against him.
Ehud Barak Professional/Team Danny Yatom
Barak refers to him as part of a 'strong, close team' and appointed him.

Key Quotes (3)

"Past sins cannot pardon future ones."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011799.jpg
Quote #1
"Every hour is good for the keeping of Shabbat."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011799.jpg
Quote #2
"The coalition doesn’t need a leader... It needs therapy."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011799.jpg
Quote #3

Full Extracted Text

Complete text extracted from the document (2,696 characters)

/ BARAK / 42
negotiations. The first stirrings of discontent had begun even before I went to see
Clinton. On the basis of my commitment merely to try for peace, Arik Sharon had
presented a no-confidence motion in the Knesset. It was never going to pass. But
only days after I’d made him Interior Minister, Natan Sharansky let it be known he
was going to vote against us. He didn’t. He stayed away from the chamber, in
effect abstaining. But I’d been put on notice.
I did lose my first coalition partner in September: the small United Torah
Judaism party, with five Knesset seats. It wasn’t over land-for-peace. In an echo of
a similar crisis that brought down the government during Rabin’s first spell as
Prime Minister in the 1970s, it was over a violation of the Jewish Sabbath. It
turned out that Israel’s state electric company had been transporting a huge steam-
condensation machine from the manufacturing site near Haifa to a power plant in
Ashdod. The unit was the size of a small apartment. It weighed 100 tons. It
couldn’t be driven across the country without bringing weekday traffic to a
standstill. The obvious solution was to do it when road use was lightest, on
Shabbat. Precisely the same procedure had been followed – 24 times – under Bibi.
But when I asked a United Torah Judaism leader why he’d seemed happy when
Likud had waved it through, he replied: “Past sins cannot pardon future ones.” Eli
Suissa, one of the Shas ministers in the cabinet, took his side, saying: “Every hour
is good for the keeping of Shabbat.” Most other ministers agreed with me that we
should stand firm. So I did. But UTJ walked out of the government. Shas did
remain. But I was now increasingly certain that at some stage its ministers, too,
would leave.
In the midst of the Sharanksy rebellion, Haim Ramon, who was the minister in
charge of liaising with the Knesset, insisted I “punish” him for his political
grandstanding. “You should fire Sharansky. Act like a leader!” I just laughed. “The
coalition doesn’t need a leader,” I replied. “It needs therapy.” In truth, I suspected
that if we ever got near to a peace agreement with Assad or Arafat, even therapy
might not help. But that was a main reason that I’d promised a referendum on any
final peace deals. I believed that in the choice between concessions, even painful
ones, and a genuine peace deal with Syria or the Palestinians, by far most Israelis
would choose peace.
I relied on a strong, close team around me, people I knew well and who shared
my determination to stay focused on the central goal: to put Israel in a position
where its citizens could be given that choice. I made Danny Yatom, my former
328
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011799

Discussion 0

Sign in to join the discussion

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document