Relationship Details

Lourie Professional Menchel

Connected Entities

Entity A
Lourie
Type: person
Mentions: 286
Also known as: Matthew Lourie
Entity B
Menchel
Type: person
Mentions: 201

Evidence

Lourie sent an 'early email to Menchel' and later 'opined to Acosta and Menchel'.

Lourie, a prosecutor, made a recommendation to his higher-level supervisor, Menchel, regarding a meeting with defense counsel.

They worked together to conduct a 'granular review' of the charging package. Lourie sent a key memorandum with Menchel's concurrence and reported information to him.

Lourie forwarded memos and reported to Menchel regarding case strategy.

Lourie forwarded prosecution memorandum to Menchel.

Source Documents (5)

DOJ-OGR-00021358.jpg

Unknown type • 984 KB
View

This legal document details a series of meetings and communications in 2007 between federal prosecutors (USAO) and Jeffrey Epstein's defense team regarding a potential prosecution. It outlines the strategic maneuvering on both sides, including the defense's presentation of legal arguments and the prosecutors' internal deliberations, led by figures like Acosta and Lourie, on charging strategy and a potential non-prosecution agreement. The document highlights key meetings in June and September 2007 where the parties exchanged information and argued their positions.

DOJ-OGR-00021347.jpg

legal document • 1.05 MB
View

This legal document details internal discussions and challenges within the prosecution team handling the Jeffrey Epstein case. It reveals concerns among prosecutors like Acosta, Lourie, and Sloman regarding victim testimony, legal weaknesses, and setting unfavorable federal precedent, contrasting with Villafaña's proposed charges. The document highlights the complexity of the case, including victims' reluctance to testify, credibility issues raised by the defense, and the influence of Acosta's past role in the Civil Rights Division on his legal strategy.

DOJ-OGR-00021227.jpg

Legal Document • 991 KB
View

This document details internal discussions within the U.S. Attorney's Office in Miami during May-June 2007 regarding the Jeffrey Epstein case. It describes how prosecutor Villafaña submitted a memorandum seeking to file charges by May 15, but her managers, including Sloman, Menchel, and Lourie, paused the process to conduct a more thorough review, including seeking analysis from the DOJ's CEOS section. The document highlights the tension between the desire to move quickly on the indictment, as pushed by the FBI, and the managers' more cautious approach, which ultimately delayed the charges.

DOJ-OGR-00021226.jpg

DOJ OPR Report / Legal Exhibit • 927 KB
View

This document is a page from a DOJ OPR report detailing internal communications between federal prosecutors (Lourie, Menchel) regarding the initial prosecution memorandum for the Jeffrey Epstein case. It highlights the prosecutors' concerns about Epstein's high-profile defense team, the belief that state prosecutors intentionally sabotaged the case in the grand jury, and strategic discussions about selecting 'clean' victims to ensure a successful indictment. The document also notes Acosta's lack of recollection regarding reading the specific prosecution memo, citing his reliance on senior staff.

DOJ-OGR-00021342.jpg

Department of Justice OPR Report • 1000 KB
View

This page from a DOJ OPR report concludes that there was no evidence that the Non-Prosecution Agreement (NPA) or the investigation into Jeffrey Epstein was influenced by bribes, corruption, or his wealth and status. It notes that while Epstein was not initially well-known to the FBI agents or prosecutors in 2006, press coverage in July 2006 alerted them to his high-profile connections, including Bill Clinton, Donald Trump, and Kevin Spacey. An FBI agent is quoted acknowledging they knew who had been on Epstein's plane.

Mutual Connections

Entities connected to both Lourie and Menchel

OPR (person)
US v. Epstein Case (person)
Sanchez (person)
Oosterbaan (person)
Alex Acosta (person)
Sloman (person)
Acosta (person)
Epstein (person)
Villafaña (person)
Marie Villafaña (person)

Lourie's Other Relationships

Business associate Villafaña
Strength: 19/10 View
Professional Villafaña
Strength: 10/10 View
Professional Acosta
Strength: 10/10 View
Business associate Acosta
Strength: 9/10 View
Professional Oosterbaan
Strength: 7/10 View

Menchel's Other Relationships

Business associate Villafaña
Strength: 14/10 View
Professional Villafaña
Strength: 10/10 View
Professional Acosta
Strength: 10/10 View
Professional Sanchez
Strength: 7/10 View
Professional Sloman
Strength: 7/10 View

Relationship Metadata

Type
Professional
Relationship Strength
9/10
Strong relationship with substantial evidence
Source Documents
5
Extracted
2025-11-20 15:15
Last Updated
2025-12-26 12:52

Entity Network Stats

Lourie 59 relationships
Menchel 52 relationships
Mutual connections 10

Discussion 0

Sign in to join the discussion

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein relationship