HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011754.jpg

2.57 MB

Extraction Summary

8
People
3
Organizations
5
Locations
2
Events
3
Relationships
5
Quotes

Document Information

Type: Book excerpt / memoir page (evidence production)
File Size: 2.57 MB
Summary

This document appears to be a page (283) from a memoir, likely by Ehud Barak (based on the description of his former roles), produced as part of a House Oversight investigation. The text details diplomatic maneuvers between Israel and Syria in the mid-1990s, specifically focusing on Shimon Peres's strategy to 'dazzle and befuddle' President Assad with complex proposals to distract from the Golan Heights issue. It recounts interactions with Arab foreign ministers and internal Israeli strategy meetings involving Peres, the narrator, and Itamar Rabinovich.

People (8)

Name Role Context
Narrator Author/Former Head of Intelligence and Chief of Staff
Likely Ehud Barak based on the description of roles (head of intelligence/chief of staff) and context of Israeli poli...
Amr Moussa Foreign Minister of Egypt
Had a good talk with the narrator at a banqueting hall.
Farouk al-Sharaa Foreign Minister of Syria
Refused to converse with the narrator, calling it inappropriate.
Hafez al-Assad President of Syria
Described as a 'bulldog' focused on the Golan Heights; in personal control of Syrian talks.
Yitzhak Rabin Former Prime Minister of Israel
Deceased; mentioned regarding previous negotiations and the 'pocket deposit'.
Shimon Peres Prime Minister of Israel
Proposed a 'dazzle and befuddle' strategy for negotiations; hosting meetings in Jerusalem.
Bill Clinton President of the United States
Scheduled to meet with Peres in Washington.
Itamar Rabinovich Diplomat/Negotiator
Briefed Peres alongside the narrator regarding Syrian talks.

Organizations (3)

Name Type Context
Labor Party
Political party headed by Shimon Peres.
Knesset
Israeli Parliament; mentioned in the context of electoral rules.
House Oversight Committee
Implied by the footer stamp 'HOUSE_OVERSIGHT'.

Timeline (2 events)

Early December
Meeting at Peres's home in Jerusalem to plan negotiation strategy before Washington visit.
Jerusalem
Upcoming (relative to text)
Peres's visit to Washington for talks with President Clinton.
Washington

Locations (5)

Location Context
Banqueting Hall
Location of an international dinner where the narrator met foreign ministers.
Country where the narrator returned.
Location of Shimon Peres's home.
Location of upcoming talks with President Clinton.
Territory central to the negotiation dispute ('the ankle').

Relationships (3)

Narrator Advisor/Subordinate Shimon Peres
Narrator briefed Peres; attended strategy meetings at Peres's home.
Shimon Peres Successor/Colleague Yitzhak Rabin
Peres continuing negotiations started under Rabin; referencing Rabin's 'pocket deposit'.
Hafez al-Assad Adversary/Negotiating Partner Israel
Assad demanding return of Golan; broken off talks; described as a bulldog.

Key Quotes (5)

"The best results are extracted from confusion"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011754.jpg
Quote #1
"It comes into your living room with one aim: to lock on to your ankle. You can throw fireworks, cookies, balloons, a tasty bone. But it's a bulldog. It's still going to move another step toward your ankle."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011754.jpg
Quote #2
"dazzle and befuddle"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011754.jpg
Quote #3
"shock and awe"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011754.jpg
Quote #4
"pocket deposit"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011754.jpg
Quote #5

Full Extracted Text

Complete text extracted from the document (2,893 characters)

ministers when we'd arrived in the banqueting hall. I did have a good talk with Egypt's Amr Moussa, and the foreign ministers of Morocco and Tunisia. When I tried to start a conversation with Syria's Farouk al-Sharaa, however, he pointedly, though politely, said he felt that would not be appropriate. President Assad had broken off talks with us earlier in the year, insisting that we first commit explicitly to honor Rabin's "pocket deposit" on the Golan Heights. Still, in my formal remarks at the dinner, I urged both sides to resume our effort to negotiate an Israeli-Syrian agreement. Sharaa's response was, again, unencouraging. But I did notice, and take heart from, the fact that it was neither polemic nor overtly hostile towards Israel.
When I returned to Israel, I found that Peres, too, wanted to restart the negotiating process with the Syrians. The effort took on fresh momentum after a meeting at Peres's home in Jerusalem in early December, ahead of his visit to Washington for talks with President Clinton. Itamar Rabinovich and I had each met with him separately a few weeks earlier to brief him on how the talks with the Syrians had gone under Rabin, and why they'd reached an impasse. We emphasized Assad's insistence on a preemptive agreement on our leaving the Golan. Peres now came forward with a plan. It was the diplomatic equivalent of what the Americans, a few years later in the second Gulf War, would call "shock and awe." This was "dazzle and befuddle." As Peres explained it, we would flood Assad with proposals: not just on land or security, but everything from water and electricity to tourism and industrial zones. Assad was in personal control of the Syrian side of the talks. The mere volume, range and complexity of the simultaneous engagement Peres had in mind would, he hoped, dilute his focus on the Golan. "The best results are extracted from confusion," he said. Having watched President Assad operate for years, when I was head of intelligence and chief of staff, I said I was skeptical. I used the image of a bulldog. "It comes into your living room with one aim: to lock on to your ankle. You can throw fireworks, cookies, balloons, a tasty bone. But it's a bulldog. It's still going to move another step toward your ankle." For Assad, the ankle was the Golan.
I understood why Peres wanted to make a new effort to get peace with Syria. Obviously, it was something to be desired in itself. It would transform the terms of our conflict with the Arabs, and maybe even bring within reach the hope of ending it altogether. But there was a political consideration as well. For all his other accomplishments, Peres had a record of repeated electoral defeat as head of Labor. This next election would be the first held under a new set of rules. Instead of merely choosing lists of Knesset candidates, Israelis would cast two
283
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011754

Discussion 0

Sign in to join the discussion

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document