HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023358.jpg

2.96 MB

Extraction Summary

18
People
4
Organizations
3
Locations
4
Events
3
Relationships
6
Quotes

Document Information

Type: Email chain / correspondence (house oversight committee document)
File Size: 2.96 MB
Summary

This document is a chain of emails from October 2015, likely written by Jeffrey Epstein to Melanie Spinella (assistant to Leon Black). The sender aggressively critiques the recipient's family office ('Elysium'), suggesting a 'heart operation' to restart it from scratch due to incompetence, poor IT, and financial mismanagement. The text details specific financial disputes, including a $2 million payment to the sender and a $5 million foundation contribution, while discussing assets like Apollo stock, Phaidon publishing, a private plane (partially owned by 'Debra'), and various staff members.

People (18)

Name Role Context
Melanie Spinella Recipient
Receiving emails on behalf of the primary subject (likely Leon Black given the context of 'Apollo stock' and 'Phaidon').
Sender (Implied Jeffrey Epstein) Advisor/Sender
Giving aggressive financial and structural advice regarding a family office; mentions 'wean yourself away from me'. R...
Brad Employee/Trustee
Working in the family office; grade moved from D- to C-; suggested to replace Richard as trustee.
Richard Trustee
Being replaced.
Barry Cohen Potential Trustee
Described as perfect but 'carries the trustee taint now'.
Joslin Employee/Associate
Needs replacing; cost '1 + mil'; sender met with Joslin recently.
Heather Staff
Advised to keep her.
Samantha (ssmantha) Staff
Advised to keep her.
Jack Robertson Associate/Advisor
Gave advice on renovating sender's first house.
Tom Tax/Finance
Not useful in the end.
Rich Tax/Finance
Not useful in the end.
Alan Tax/Finance
Described as 'the only smart one'.
Joe Associate
Suggested to bring him over.
Debra Family Member (Debra Black)
Owns 49 percent of plane.
Ben Family Member (Ben Black)
His house is 'unaccounted for'.
Regan Associate (Judith Regan)
Associated with 'art space'; needs more cash.
Leon Subject (Leon Black)
Mentioned in the third email: 'leon seems to have replaced Eillenn'.
Eillenn Former Staff/Associate
Replaced by Leon.

Organizations (4)

Name Type Context
Apollo
Stock mentioned ('apollo stock could be sold').
Elysium
Family office entity; advised to 'close down the mess of elysium forever'.
Phaidon
Publishing company; 'looks like close to breakeven in a few years'.
House Oversight Committee
Document source (Footer).

Timeline (4 events)

Dec 2013
Sender suggested starting the office from scratch.
Unknown
Sender Recipient
July 2015
Sender said to focus on airplane as a test.
Unknown
Sender
Nov 2014
Sender laid out IT priorities.
Unknown
Sender
Oct 19, 2015
Sender spent time with Joslin and Joe.
Unknown
Sender Joslin Joe Brad

Locations (3)

Location Context
Mentioned regarding lighting contractor and IT.
Unaccounted for.
Argued as third home; will cost to refinance if sold.

Relationships (3)

Sender (Epstein) Advisor / Financial Manager Leon Black (Implied Recipient/Subject)
Sender provides deep structural advice on family office, discusses payments of $2M to himself, and suggests weaning the subject off his help.
Leon Black Spouse Debra Black
Implied by 'your wife heirs' and 'debra owns 49 percent of plane'.
Brad Colleague / Successor Richard
Suggestion to move Brad to be the replacement for Richard as trustee.

Key Quotes (6)

"Your office is the heart of the familys financial life and temp future, it needs a heart operation"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023358.jpg
Quote #1
"The best way to wean yourself away from me is to have someone else do the whole thing from scratch."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023358.jpg
Quote #2
"what you thought was ultimately fair was the contribution of 5 million to a foundation and a total of 2 million dollars to me."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023358.jpg
Quote #3
"START from total scratch. there is absolutely nothing worth keeping in your family office except for heather"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023358.jpg
Quote #4
"close down the mess of elysium forever"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023358.jpg
Quote #5
"only last week told debra owns 49 percent of plane"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023358.jpg
Quote #6

Full Extracted Text

Complete text extracted from the document (4,387 characters)

With your full knowledge I paid out 8 mil to my staff before june, . so i guess I can safely assume that after consideration of all the things I did for the entire past year separate and apart from your unique free "after care" concept. , what you thought was ultimately fair was the contribution of 5 million to a foundation and a total of 2 million dollars to me.
Date: Fri, Oct 16, 2015 at 1:08 PM
Subject:
To: Melanie Spinella [REDACTED]
I think you should consider the fact that your family office will be the most central component of what you leave to your children , wife heirs. it is the core of your assets. your art might be sold. your houses may lie empty, the apollo stock could be sold. you will pass on your office , . it will be the primary player in your estate tax. probate, transition. Brad has taken it from a D minus to a C minus, If I were you I would set the goal of an A. just like your paintings. . Like a house you could attempt to renovate it. it will take more time and money . or . in essence as I suggested in dec of 13, start from scratch. A financail head of office. - brad could move to being richards replacment as trustee. . barry cohen would be perfect but carries the trustee taint now. . take a tax partner from a major firm. to replace joslin, cost 1 + mil . keep heather and ssmantha. . bring in full time IT person. ASAP . your lighting contractor in your new townhouse has better IT than your multi billlion dollar antique opersation. data breaches are not your concern. precision is. . either re do the office layout . or get enterly new space. the proposals to focus on following on a monthly basis the values of all your current investments is an example of misplaced prioirties. . Your office is the heart of the familys financial life and temp future, it needs a heart operation
Date: Mon, Oct 19, 2015 at 5:10 PM
Subject:
To: Melanie Spinella [REDACTED]
Radical but my preferred idea. . START from total scratch. there is absolutely nothing worth keeping in your family office except for heather , nothing at all . I remember when i bought my first house in order to renovate and jack robertson said forget it. knock it down start again, I could n't believe it. but he was right. Like your tax returns that were done in triplicate. TOM RICH ALAN. . tom and rich were not really useful in the end. Alan was the only smart one. you should in my opinion Start a brand new office. hire cfo. bring joe over. heather and samantha, run parallel for 6 months and close down the mess of elysium forever. leave your kids a functioning operation professionally constructed and managed. NOT BY ME!!! LAst nov i laid out priorities IT , being the first nothing as of today. in July I said focus on airplane as a test . to examine procedure and proficiency, so far mostly a waste of resources time people etc. Only last week told debra owns 49 percent of plane. no IT to speak of. bens house unaccounted for. tax returns very very sloppy, . boat still argued as third home. . pilots bonuses? , structure unkown by all. cash sitlling at the same time loans outstanding.
Phaidon , looks like close to breakeven in a few years. others totally unknown. Query , do you really want this ? : I m not sure how you both want to have an investment office and have cash flow being eaten by publishing and loans amounts outstanding increased by art. --interest rates will be going up.- . your plane will cost 10 million to refinance - so will boat if sold next year-. art space and regan , both needs more cash. with little return, taxes , art purchases . Part of radical solutition is to sell publishing.altogether. (are the children really interested.) . restrucuture plane from scratch. layers unncessary. simplify crazy structure s bank accounts trading accounts accounts payable. credit cards. etc. The best way to wean yourself away from me is to have someone else do the whole thing from scratch. . move brad to be the replacement for Richard. . he is nice but this is not what he does. Him saying it is soooo fucked up to me , was only an echo of me sayint it to you. .
Subject:
To: Melanie Spinella [REDACTED]
as brad can attest , I spent time today with joslin, joe. etc. no question at all, a failed experiment. In the words of a banker that made a call on your office. what happened? leon seems to have replaced Eillenn with a
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023358

Discussion 0

Sign in to join the discussion

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document