HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019643.jpg

1.64 MB

Extraction Summary

9
People
6
Organizations
4
Locations
1
Events
4
Relationships
3
Quotes

Document Information

Type: Book page / congressional exhibit
File Size: 1.64 MB
Summary

This document is page 155 from a book (likely 'How America Lost Its Secrets' by Edward Jay Epstein, indicated by the filename 'Epst' and ISBN 9780451494566), marked as a House Oversight exhibit. The text speculates on whether Edward Snowden had a hidden collaborator within the NSA, drawing parallels to historical Russian moles like Robert Hanssen and Aldrich Ames. It includes details of an interview the author conducted with KGB handler Victor Cherkashin in Moscow in 2015 regarding the ability of intelligence services to hide moles.

People (9)

Name Role Context
Edward Snowden Subject/NSA Leaker
Discussed regarding his potential collaboration with Russian intelligence.
Laura Poitras Filmmaker/Journalist
Associate of Snowden in Hong Kong.
Glenn Greenwald Journalist
Associate of Snowden in Hong Kong; told by Snowden he wanted to divert suspicion.
Carl Sagan Astronomer
Quoted regarding 'absence of evidence'.
Robert Hanssen FBI Agent / KGB Mole
Cited as an example of a mole who eluded detection for 20 years.
Aldrich Ames CIA Officer / KGB Mole
Cited as an example of a mole who eluded detection for 10 years.
Victor Cherkashin KGB Case Officer
Interviewed by the author in Moscow in 2015 regarding Hanssen and Ames.
James Jesus Angleton CIA Counterintelligence Chief
Mentioned regarding his 'paranoid mind' about moles.
Edward Jay Epstein Author (Implied)
The narrator ('I') interviewing Cherkashin; filename 'Epst' refers to his book.

Organizations (6)

Name Type Context
NSA
National Security Agency, target of Snowden's leaks.
Booz Allen
Consulting firm where Snowden was employed.
FBI
Federal Bureau of Investigation, penetrated by Hanssen.
KGB
Soviet intelligence agency, handler of Hanssen and Ames.
CIA
Central Intelligence Agency, penetrated by Ames.
Russian intelligence services
General reference to foreign intelligence capabilities.

Timeline (1 events)

2015
Interview between the author and KGB officer Victor Cherkashin.
Moscow

Locations (4)

Location Context
Location where Snowden met Poitras and Greenwald.
Location where Snowden worked; potential location of a collaborator.
Location of the 2015 interview with Victor Cherkashin.
Referenced as U.S. intelligence.

Relationships (4)

Edward Snowden Source/Journalist Glenn Greenwald
Snowden told Greenwald to divert suspicion.
Edward Snowden Source/Journalist Laura Poitras
Made video with Poitras in Hong Kong.
Victor Cherkashin Handler/Asset Robert Hanssen
Cherkashin identified as their KGB case officer.
Victor Cherkashin Handler/Asset Aldrich Ames
Cherkashin identified as their KGB case officer.

Key Quotes (3)

"absence of evidence is not evidence of absence."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019643.jpg
Quote #1
"The greatest trick the devil ever pulled was convincing the world he didn't exist"
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019643.jpg
Quote #2
"CIA denial [of moles] certainly helped."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019643.jpg
Quote #3

Full Extracted Text

Complete text extracted from the document (2,425 characters)

Did Snowden Act Alone? | 155
shared Snowden's anti-surveillance views. If Snowden then voiced an interest in exposing the NSA's secrets, this person could supply him with the necessary guidance, steering a still-unsuspecting Snowden first to the Booz Allen position and afterward to his associates in Hong Kong. By taking sole credit for the coup in the video that he made with Poitras and Greenwald in Hong Kong, he acted, as he told Greenwald, to divert suspicion from anyone else. This move could also give any collaborator he might have had in Hawaii time to cover his or her tracks.
The astronomer Carl Sagan famously said in regard to searching the universe for signals from other civilizations that the "absence of evidence is not evidence of absence." That injunction also applies to the spooky universe of espionage. The fact that a mole hunt fails to find a hidden collaborator at the NSA does not necessarily mean such a mole does not exist. Historically, we have many notable cases in which Russian moles eluded long, intensive investigations. Robert Hanssen penetrated the FBI for over twenty years for the KGB without being caught. Similarly, Aldrich Ames acted as a KGB mole in the CIA for more than ten years and passed all the CIA's sophisticated lie detector tests. Both Hanssen and Ames eluded intensive FBI and CIA investigations that lasted over a decade. According to Victor Cherkashin, their KGB case officer, whom I interviewed in Moscow in 2015, the KGB was able to hide their existence from investigators for such a long period partly because of the widespread belief in U.S. intelligence that moles were fictional creatures that sprang from the "paranoid mind" of James Jesus Angleton. When I then cited the signature line from the movie The Usual Suspects, "The greatest trick the devil ever pulled was convincing the world he didn't exist," Cherkashin thinly smiled and said, "CIA denial [of moles] certainly helped."
In view of such past successes of the Russian intelligence services, it cannot be precluded that there was another person in the NSA working with the enthusiastic Snowden as cover to prevent any light from falling on his own surreptitious spying. While it may seem extremely unlikely that Snowden had such assistance, the alternative scenario, that Snowden broke into the sealed compartments and
Epst_9780451494566_2p_all_r1.z.indd 155
9/29/16 5:51 PM
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019643

Discussion 0

Sign in to join the discussion

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document