HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028442.jpg

3.45 MB

Extraction Summary

9
People
9
Organizations
1
Locations
3
Events
4
Relationships
4
Quotes

Document Information

Type: News article / commentary (submitted as evidence to house oversight)
File Size: 3.45 MB
Summary

This document, marked 'HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028442', is a commentary piece from circa late September 2018 analyzing the cultural impact of the #MeToo movement in the context of the Brett Kavanaugh Supreme Court confirmation. It focuses on the allegations made by Deborah Ramirez, as reported in The New Yorker, arguing that women are increasingly demanding that their fragmented but deeply felt memories of trauma be taken seriously, even against staunch denials from powerful men. The author contrasts Ramirez's case with the past experiences of Anita Hill and the more recent, tragic story of Amber Wyatt to illustrate a shift in expectations about whose stories are heard and believed.

People (9)

Name Role Context
Brett Kavanaugh Supreme Court Nominee
Accused by Deborah Ramirez of sexual misconduct while they were classmates at Yale. His nomination to the Supreme Cou...
Deborah Ramirez Accuser
Subject of a New Yorker article who accused her Yale classmate, Brett Kavanaugh, of exposing himself to her at a coll...
Anita Hill Historical Figure
Mentioned as a historical precedent, 27 years prior, for women speaking out about sexual harassment against powerful ...
Tarana Burke Activist / Founder
Credited as the founder of the 'Me Too' movement, 12 years prior to the events discussed.
Jane Mayer Journalist
Co-author of the New Yorker article that detailed Deborah Ramirez's allegations against Brett Kavanaugh.
Ronan Farrow Journalist
Co-author of the New Yorker article that detailed Deborah Ramirez's allegations against Brett Kavanaugh.
Christine Blasey Ford Accuser
Mentioned as another woman who, like Ramirez, came forward with allegations and opened her story to investigation.
Elizabeth Bruenig Journalist
Washington Post writer who reported on the rape of Amber Wyatt.
Amber Wyatt Assault Victim
A 16-year-old from Texas whose rape allegation from 12 years prior was the subject of a Washington Post report by Eli...

Timeline (3 events)

Circa 2006
Alleged rape of 16-year-old Amber Wyatt, who was taken to a shed by two boys and sexually assaulted after a party.
Texas
Circa September 2018
The confirmation process for Brett Kavanaugh's nomination to the Supreme Court, which became a high-stakes political battle following sexual assault allegations.
Washington, D.C.
Circa early-to-mid 1980s
Alleged sexual misconduct incident where Brett Kavanaugh exposed his penis to Deborah Ramirez against her will during a college party.
Yale

Locations (1)

Location Context

Relationships (4)

Brett Kavanaugh Accused-Accuser / Classmates Deborah Ramirez
The document states they were Yale classmates and that Ramirez accused Kavanaugh of sexual misconduct.
Brett Kavanaugh Accused-Accuser Christine Blasey Ford
The document mentions Christine Blasey Ford as another individual who accused Kavanaugh and opened her story to investigation.
Jane Mayer Colleagues / Co-authors Ronan Farrow
The document identifies them as co-authors of the New Yorker piece.
Elizabeth Bruenig Journalist-Subject Amber Wyatt
The document describes Bruenig's reporting on the story of Amber Wyatt.

Key Quotes (4)

"Women... are refusing to stop speaking about their experiences, their perspectives, their memories. By doing so, they’re expanding the boundaries of what kinds of stories must be taken seriously – and bringing a much fuller picture of female humanity into view."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028442.jpg
Quote #1
"What she did remember was her Yale classmate Brett Kavanaugh pulling down his pants and thrusting his penis in her face against her will."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028442.jpg
Quote #2
"The imperfection of her victimhood did not stop her from speaking, from insisting that her view of events should count just as much as the blithe, blanket denials being issued by a man..."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028442.jpg
Quote #3
"Everyone started blaming [Wyatt] because she said something, and if she would have kept her mouth shut then nothing would have ever happened."
Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028442.jpg
Quote #4

Full Extracted Text

Complete text extracted from the document (5,351 characters)

A", "range":{"length":16,"start":371},"type":"link"}],"identifier":" anf-body-4","inlineTextStyles":[{"range":{"length":619,"start":0},"textstyle":"anf-ts-11"},{"range":{"length":3,"start":173},"textStyle":" anf-ts-10"}],"layout":"bodyContentLayout","role":"body","text":"That change is happening whether or not Republicans push Kavanaugh through, whether or not Democrats take the House or the Senate. The change is not simply (or perhaps, not yet) about outcomes, but rather about expectations and what it’s okay to talk about and when. Women â€" 27 years after Anita Hill, 12 years after Tarana Burke’s Me Too, and one year into #MeToo â€" are refusing to stop speaking about their experiences, their perspectives, their memories. By doing so, they’re expanding the boundaries of what kinds of stories must be taken seriously â€" and bringing a much fuller picture of female humanity into view.","type":"text"},{"additions":[{"URL":"https://apple.news/A3a5du8CBSk-YrrB4JgycQw","range":{"length":12,"start":87},"type":"link"},{"URL":"https://apple.news/AEoAndznRQDi2nA0rwpKTOA","range":{"length":30,"start":747},"type":"link"}],"identifier":" anf-body-5","inlineTextStyles":[{"range":{"length":854,"start":0},"textStyle":"anf-ts-11"},{"range":{"length":11,"start":51},"textStyle":"anf-ts-10"}],"layout":"bodyContentLayout","role":"body","text":"I thought about this forced shift when I opened the New Yorker piece by Jane Mayer and Ronan Farrow on Sunday night, and read about the kind of encounter most women I know have always assumed they’d never be able to recount in public â€" least of all in the midst of a highly scrutinized, high-stakes political battle â€" because it didn’t meet the impossibly high standards the world has set for women who’ve been abused or assaulted and want to be believed. The story was told by Deborah Ramirez, who told Mayer and Farrow that she almost didn’t come forward â€" even with a lifetime appointment to the Supreme Court in the balance â€" because what she had to relate happened one night in college when she’d been drinking. What she did remember was her Yale classmate Brett Kavanaugh pulling down his pants and thrusting his penis in her face against her will.","type":"text"},{"additions":[{"URL":"https://apple.news/AMN_04a95QdyVaSlT0eQzPA","range":{"length":21,"start":317},"type":"link"}],"identifier":" anf-body-6","inlineTextStyles":[{"range":{"length":708,"start":0},"textstyle":"_anf-ts-11"},{"range":{"length":3,"start":458},"textStyle":"anf-ts-10"}],"layout":"bodyContentLayout","role":"body","text":"Ramirez openly admits that her memory is patchy, that only flashes are clear, that she was drunk to the point of slurring. Each of these things, she clearly understands, undermines her tale, leaves her open to a different kind of assault now, 35 years later. And yet she not only decided to tell her story; she, like Christine Blasey Ford, opened it up to investigation. The imperfection of her victimhood did not stop her from speaking, from insisting that her view of events should count just as much as the blithe, blanket denials being issued by a man we have no reason to believe remembers his drunken youth any more clearly than she remembers hers, yet whose word is reflexively granted more authority.","type":"text"},{"additions":[{"URL":"https://apple.news/AcQZ0Mp-TQg04sysZiGbcJQ","range":{"length":20,"start":140},"type":"link"}],"identifier":"_anf-body-7","inlineTextStyles":[{"range":{"length":1257,"start":0},"textStyle":"_anf-ts-11"},{"range":{"length":4,"start":108},"textStyle":"anf-ts-10"}],"layout":"bodyContentLayout","role":"body","text":"Ramirez’s willingness to speak was particularly affecting in the same week as the publication of Washington Post writer Elizabeth Bruenig’s remarkable reporting on the rape, in her Texas hometown, of 16-year-old Amber Wyatt, 12 years ago. At the time of her alleged assault, Wyatt did tell her story, to fellow students, to her mother, and to police. But her account of how, after getting drunk and high at a party, she was taken to a shed by two boys who penetrated her vaginally and anally, and demanded that she perform oral sex, wasn’t viewed as authoritative. Neither was the investigation that followed it, which included the collection of evidence of her attack and a medical examination at a hospital. Instead, Wyatt was vilified for having caused trouble to her community; vile slurs about her penetrability were spray-painted around her town and at her school; she was sent to finish her education elsewhere, and eventually written off as having made a false accusation, the voice she’d worked so hard to raise quelled, her story recalled as fallacious. Bruenig quotes a friend of Wyatt’s who remembers, “Everyone started blaming [Wyatt] because she said something, and if she would have kept her mouth shut then nothing would have ever happened.â€","type":"text"},{"additions":[{"URL":"https://apple.news/ARif95BbdToiojzs2D y5c5w","range":{"length":16,"start":169},"type":"link"},{"URL":"https://apple.news/AbWC vXYSQQRibKkYIhU4zVA","range":{"length":18,"start":624},"type":"link"}],"identifier":" a nf-body-8","inlineTextStyles":[{"range":{"length":908,"start":0},"textstyle":"_anf-ts-11"}],"layout":"bodyContentLayout","role":"body","text":"The message to women â€"
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028442

Discussion 0

Sign in to join the discussion

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document