EFTA00027444.pdf

708 KB
View Original

Extraction Summary

4
People
7
Organizations
5
Locations
4
Events
2
Relationships
5
Quotes

Document Information

Type: Email correspondence / legal discovery chain
File Size: 708 KB
Summary

This document is a chain of emails between the US Attorney's Office (SDNY) and the FBI regarding the digital forensics processing of evidence seized from Jeffrey Epstein's properties in New York and the Virgin Islands. The correspondence highlights significant technical and logistical friction; the USANYS required data in a processed format compatible with the 'Relativity' review platform for legal discovery, while the FBI provided raw forensic dumps (phone extractions, hard drive clones) which were difficult to review. The text mentions terabytes of data, including 50+ devices, servers, and older evidence from a 2007 search, but contains no actual flight logs or passenger manifests (flight records are only mentioned hypothetically as an example of file-linking errors).

People (4)

Name Role Context
Russell Unknown (likely FBI or USANYS)
Mentioned as putting an issue on the radar of the new ASAC.
Rozier Unknown
Mentioned as able to join a conference call.
Jeffrey Epstein Subject of Investigation
Subject of search warrants and seized devices.
[REDACTED] ASAC Assistant Special Agent in Charge (FBI)
New ASAC briefed on the data processing delays.

Organizations (7)

Name Type Context
USANYS
United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York (Sender/Recipient of emails).
FBI
Federal Bureau of Investigation (Seized the evidence, responsible for processing).
CART
Computer Analysis and Response Team (FBI forensic unit).
PAE
Vendor mentioned for data processing.
Relativity
E-Discovery software platform used for document review.
Everlaw
E-Discovery software platform (mentioned as example).
Logikcull
E-Discovery software platform (mentioned as example).

Timeline (4 events)

2007-07
Previous search warrant execution mentioned where 9 IDE drives were found (copies of 3 drives).
Manhattan Apartment/Property
Jeffrey Epstein (implied)
2019-08
Seizure of evidence 'nine months ago' (approximate date based on email context).
New York and Virgin Islands
FBI
2020-02-25
Case team travel to California (mentioned as 'coming week' in email from Feb 23).
California
Case Team
2020-05-11
Call with new ASAC regarding data extraction issues.
Unknown (likely phone)
Russell USANYS Staff ASAC

Locations (5)

Location Context
Location of Epstein's mansion/apartment where devices were seized.
Specific location of apartment.
Location of Epstein's property (Little St. James) where devices/servers were seized.
Location where the case team traveled in late Feb 2020.
Jurisdiction of the US Attorney's Office.

Relationships (2)

USANYS Professional/Adversarial regarding procedure FBI/CART
Repeated complaints about data format, delays, and lack of 'loadable' files for discovery.
USANYS Vendor/Client PAE
Mentioned as the vendor who might need to process the raw data.

Key Quotes (5)

"Instead, the FBI is going to basically just give us copies of the original files from the collected devices and drives — effectively the equivalent of a phone dump, or a copy of a hard drive."
Source
EFTA00027444.pdf
Quote #1
"It's sort of like if I spent nine months working on what you expected would be a 300-page memo on a legal issue, and then instead sent you a list of a thousand relevant case citations."
Source
EFTA00027444.pdf
Quote #2
"There were 9 IDE hard drives found in the Manhattan apartment, they turned out to be 3 copies of 3 drives (9 drives in total) from a July 2007 search on one of his properties."
Source
EFTA00027444.pdf
Quote #3
"The data we've received has no way to put any emails and attachments together. So if an email says, 'see the attached flight records,' for example, we have no way of linking that up with the records themselves."
Source
EFTA00027444.pdf
Quote #4
"Relativity is NOT a forensic tool. It is incapable of dealing with many things that are found forensically on a computer like free space, slack space, and system files to name a few."
Source
EFTA00027444.pdf
Quote #5

Discussion 0

Sign in to join the discussion

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document