HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016814.jpg

Two years after Cybernetics, in 1950, Norbert Wiener published The Human Use of Human Beings—a deeper story, in which he expressed his concerns about the runaway commercial exploitation and other unforeseen consequences of the new technologies of control. I didn’t read The Human Use of Human Beings until the spring of 2016, when I picked up my copy, a first edition, which was sitting in my library next to Cybernetics. What shocked me was the realization of just how prescient Wiener was in 1950 about what’s going on today. Although the first edition was a major bestseller—and, indeed, jump-started an important conversation—under pressure from his peers Wiener brought out a revised and milder edition in 1954, from which the original concluding chapter, "Voices of Rigidity," is conspicuously absent.

Science historian George Dyson points out that in this long-forgotten first edition, Wiener predicted the possibility of a "threatening new Fascism dependent on the machine à gouverner":

No elite escaped his criticism, from the Marxists and the Jesuits ("all of Catholicism is indeed essentially a totalitarian religion") to the FBI ("our great merchant princes have looked upon the propaganda technique of the Russians, and have found that it is good") and the financiers lending their support "to make American capitalism and the fifth freedom of the businessman supreme throughout the world." Scientists . . . received the same scrutiny given the Church: "Indeed, the heads of great laboratories are very much like Bishops, with their association with the powerful in all walks of life, and the dangers they incur of the carnal sins of pride and of lust for power."

This jeremiad did not go well for Wiener. As Dyson puts it:

These alarms were discounted at the time, not because Wiener was wrong about digital computing but because larger threats were looming as he completed his manuscript in the fall of 1949. Wiener had nothing against digital computing but was strongly opposed to nuclear weapons and refused to join those who were building digital computers to move forward on the thousand-times-more-powerful hydrogen bomb.

Since the original of The Human Use of Human Beings is now out of print, lost to us is Wiener’s cri de coeur, more relevant today than when he wrote it, sixty-eight years ago: "We must cease to kiss the whip that lashes us."

Mind, Thinking, Intelligence

Among the reasons we don’t hear much about "Cybernetics" today, two are central: First, although The Human Use of Human Beings was considered an important book in its time, it ran counter to the aspirations of many of Wiener’s colleagues, including John von Neumann and Claude Shannon, who were interested in the commercialization of the new technologies. Second, computer pioneer John McCarthy disliked Wiener and refused to use Wiener’s term "Cybernetics." McCarthy, in turn, coined the term "artificial intelligence" and became a founding father of that field.

11

HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016814