HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016200.jpg
1.83 MB
Extraction Summary
19
People
3
Organizations
5
Locations
3
Events
3
Relationships
6
Quotes
Document Information
Type:
Legal declaration/affidavit
File Size:
1.83 MB
Summary
This document is a legal declaration refuting Alan Dershowitz's public claims that he never traveled without his wife and was never alone with Epstein and young women. The declarant provides specific flight log evidence from 1998, 2004, and 2005 showing Dershowitz on flights with Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell, Sarah Kellen, and other women, noting specifically that his wife was not listed on these manifests. The document also notes that Dershowitz had personal access to flight logs before they were turned over to law enforcement.
People (19)
| Name | Role | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Virginia Giuffre | Plaintiff/Victim |
Allegations of abuse filed on her behalf
|
| Mr. Edwards | Attorney |
Filed allegations with the declarant
|
| Jeffrey Epstein | Accused |
Accused of abuse; present on multiple flights
|
| Alan Dershowitz | Accused/Passenger |
Accused of abuse; flight logs show him traveling with Epstein and women without his wife
|
| Mr. Boies | Attorney |
Not informed of the filing in advance
|
| Ms. McCawley | Attorney |
Partner to Boies, not informed of filing
|
| Stan Pottinger | Attorney |
Not informed of filing in advance
|
| Ghislaine Maxwell | Passenger/Associate |
Present on flight Feb 9, 1998 (listed as GM)
|
| Emmy Taylor | Passenger |
Present on flight Feb 9, 1998 (listed as CT)
|
| Claire Hazel | Passenger |
Present on flight Feb 9, 1998
|
| Joel Pashcow | Passenger |
Present on flight Feb 9, 1998
|
| Mandy | Passenger |
Present on flight Feb 9, 1998
|
| Dubins | Passenger |
Present on flight Feb 9, 1998 (Glenn Dubin implied)
|
| Sarah Kellen | Passenger/Associate |
Present on flight Feb 5, 2004 (listed as SK)
|
| Adriana Mucinska | Passenger |
Present on flight Nov 17, 2005 (listed as AM)
|
| Tatianna Kovylskna | Passenger |
Present on flight Nov 17, 2005
|
| Sophie Biddle | Passenger |
Listed in flight log snippet
|
| Alan Weber | Passenger |
Listed in flight log snippet
|
| Joe Recarey | Police Detective |
Referenced in deposition regarding flight logs
|
Organizations (3)
| Name | Type | Context |
|---|---|---|
| American Lawyer |
Publication where Dershowitz was quoted
|
|
| Wall Street Journal |
Publication where Dershowitz was quoted
|
|
| CNN |
Network where Dershowitz was interviewed by Hala Gorani
|
Timeline (3 events)
February 5, 2004
February 9, 1998
Flight #1073 to Teterboro
Teterboro Airport
November 17, 2005
Flights #1841, #1842, #1843
Montreal, Bedford, Teterboro
Locations (5)
| Location | Context |
|---|---|
|
TEB - Frequent flight destination/origin
|
|
|
PBI - Flight destination
|
|
|
CYUL - Flight destination for Dershowitz
|
|
|
BED - Flight destination
|
|
|
TIST - Flight origin in log
|
Relationships (3)
Multiple flights together (1998, 2004, 2005) listed in logs.
Flight #1073 on Feb 9, 1998.
Ms. Virginia Giuffre's allegations of abuse by Epstein, Dershowitz...
Key Quotes (6)
"I've been married to the same woman for 28 years. She goes with me everywhere. People know that I won't argue a case or give a speech unless my wife travels with me."Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016200.jpg
Quote #1
"I was never alone with Jeffrey Epstein in the company of any young women. I can tell you that unequivocally."Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016200.jpg
Quote #2
"As far as the planes are concerned, there are flight manifests. They will prove I was never on any private airplane with any young women."Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016200.jpg
Quote #3
"Contrary to these assertions, evidence I possessed showed the following things."Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016200.jpg
Quote #4
"On February 9, 1998, Alan Dershowitz appears on flight #1073... without his wife."Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016200.jpg
Quote #5
"it appears that Mr. Dershowitz had access to the flight logs before they were produced to law enforcement authorities."Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016200.jpg
Quote #6
Full Extracted Text
Complete text extracted from the document (3,929 characters)
Case 1:19-cv-03377-LAP Document 36-4 Filed 07/03/19 Page 4 of 6
24. After more than six months of follow-up investigation, on December 30, 2014, Mr. Edwards and I filed Ms. Virginia Giuffre's allegations of abuse by Epstein, Dershowitz, and others in the CVRA case as part of a motion for her to join the CVRA case. The decision to file was made by Mr. Edwards and me. To the best of my recollection, I did not inform Mr. Boies of our intentions and, to my knowledge, neither he, nor his partner Ms. McCawley, nor attorney Stan Pottinger, were informed in advance of the date or contents of the filing.
33. In the course of those public attacks, Mr. Dershowitz made a number of statements to the press that were inconsistent with information that I possessed.
34. Dershowitz said, for example, that his wife accompanied him everywhere: "I've been married to the same woman for 28 years. She goes with me everywhere. People know that I won't argue a case or give a speech unless my wife travels with me." (American Lawyer, Jan. 15, 2015.) Dershowitz also denied being with Epstein in the company of young women: "I was never alone with Jeffrey Epstein in the company of any young women. I can tell you that unequivocally." (Wall Street Journal, Jan. 2, 2015). He cited flight manifests: "As far as the planes are concerned, there are flight manifests. They will prove I was never on any private airplane with any young women." (Hala Gorani, CNN Live, Jan. 5, 2015).
35. Contrary to these assertions, evidence I possessed showed the following things.
36. On February 9, 1998, Alan Dershowitz appears on flight #1073 to Teterboro Airport with Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell, Emmy Taylor, Claire Hazel, Joel Pashcow, one unidentified female, Mandy and Dubins +1 (without his wife).
[Flight Log Image 1]
[Row 1] 11 | 11 | PBI | TEB | 1071 | JE, SOPHIE BIDDLE | L
[Row 2] 11 | 11 | TEB | PBI | 1072 | JE, GM, CT, SOPHIE BIDDLE, EVA, GLEN | L
[Row 3] 9 | 11 | 11 | PBI | TEB | 1073 | JE, GM, CT, CLAIRE HAZEL, JOEL PASHCOW, | L
[Row 3 continued] | | | | | ALAN DERSHOWITZ, MANDY, DUBINS +1 |
[Row 1] 11 | 11 | PBI | TEB | 1071 | JE, SOPHIE BIDDLE | L
[Row 2] 11 | 11 | TEB | PBI | 1072 | JE, GM, CT, SOPHIE BIDDLE, EVA, GLEN | L
[Row 3] 9 | 11 | 11 | PBI | TEB | 1073 | JE, GM, CT, CLAIRE HAZEL, JOEL PASHCOW, | L
[Row 3 continued] | | | | | ALAN DERSHOWITZ, MANDY, DUBINS +1 |
37. On February 5, 2004, Alan Dershowitz appears on flight #1695 to Teterboro Airport, then boards flight #1696 to Palm Beach with Epstein and Sarah Kellen (without his wife).
[Flight Log Image 2]
[Row 1] FEB 5 | " | " | TIST | TEB | 1693 | JE, SK, SLB, VM, TP, SK, ALAN WEBER | L
[Row 2] 5 | " | " | TEB | BED | 1694 | | LV
[Row 3] 5 | " | " | BED | PBI | 1695 | ALAN DERSHOWITZ | LV
[Row 4] 5 | " | " | TEB | PBI | 1696 | JE, AP, SK | LV
[Row 1] FEB 5 | " | " | TIST | TEB | 1693 | JE, SK, SLB, VM, TP, SK, ALAN WEBER | L
[Row 2] 5 | " | " | TEB | BED | 1694 | | LV
[Row 3] 5 | " | " | BED | PBI | 1695 | ALAN DERSHOWITZ | LV
[Row 4] 5 | " | " | TEB | PBI | 1696 | JE, AP, SK | LV
38. On November 17, 2005, Alan Dershowitz appears on flight #1841 to Montreal, Canada, then boards flight #1842 to Bedford, then #1843 to Teterboro with Epstein, Adriana Mucinska (AM), and Tatianna Kovylskna (without his wife).
[Flight Log Image 3]
[Header] Date | N# | From | To | Flight # | Passengers
[Row 1] Nov 12 | G-1159B | N908JE | TEB | TIST | 1838 | JE, ADRIANA MUCINSKA, TATIANNA KOVYLSKNA, NM, SK, [illegible] | SH
[Row 2] 16 | " | " | TIST | TEB | 1839 | JE, AM, [illegible], NM | LV
[Row 3] 17 | " | " | TEB | BED | 1840 | JE, AM | LV
[Row 4] 17 | " | " | BED | CYUL | 1841 | ALAN DERSHOWITZ | LV
[Row 5] 17 | " | " | CYUL | BED | 1842 | ALAN DERSHOWITZ | LV
[Row 6] 17 | " | " | BED | TEB | 1843 | JE, AM, AD, TATIANNA | LV
[Header] Date | N# | From | To | Flight # | Passengers
[Row 1] Nov 12 | G-1159B | N908JE | TEB | TIST | 1838 | JE, ADRIANA MUCINSKA, TATIANNA KOVYLSKNA, NM, SK, [illegible] | SH
[Row 2] 16 | " | " | TIST | TEB | 1839 | JE, AM, [illegible], NM | LV
[Row 3] 17 | " | " | TEB | BED | 1840 | JE, AM | LV
[Row 4] 17 | " | " | BED | CYUL | 1841 | ALAN DERSHOWITZ | LV
[Row 5] 17 | " | " | CYUL | BED | 1842 | ALAN DERSHOWITZ | LV
[Row 6] 17 | " | " | BED | TEB | 1843 | JE, AM, AD, TATIANNA | LV
39. To be clear, the flight logs that I had reviewed did not show Mr. Dershowitz alone with Ms. Giuffre. But I did not have a complete set of flight logs for the relevant time period and, in addition, it appears that Mr. Dershowitz had access to the flight logs before they were produced to law enforcement authorities. (See Police Detective Joe Recarey Depo. at 281, Jane Doe No. 2 v. Epstein, No. 9:08-cv-80119-KAM (Mar. 19, 2010) (Dershowitz personally provided the flight logs).)
40. To also be clear, the foregoing is not a complete recitation of the substantial information that I had that contradicted Mr. Dershowitz's claims.
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016200
Discussion 0
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document