HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023049.jpg
2.76 MB
Extraction Summary
21
People
9
Organizations
5
Locations
4
Events
4
Relationships
6
Quotes
Document Information
Type:
Newspaper article (the virgin islands daily news)
File Size:
2.76 MB
Summary
This article from The Virgin Islands Daily News details the 'unusual level of collaboration' between federal prosecutors (including Alexander Acosta and A. Marie Villafana) and Jeffrey Epstein's legal team during the negotiation of his non-prosecution agreement. It highlights the exclusion of victims from the process, the 'VIP treatment' Epstein received in jail (including work release authorized by Sheriff Ric Bradshaw), and subsequent legal battles by victims like 'Jane Doe No. 1' (Wild) and Jena-Lisa Jones to invalidate the agreement. The document also reveals that in 2011, the NY District Attorney's office under Cyrus Vance argued on Epstein's behalf to reduce his sex offender status, a move that shocked the presiding judge.
People (21)
| Name | Role | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Jeffrey Epstein | Subject/Accused |
Convicted sex offender, accused of molesting underage girls, received 'VIP treatment' and a lenient plea deal.
|
| Jena-Lisa Jones | Victim |
Says Epstein molested her when she was 14; quoted extensively about mental trauma.
|
| Wild | Victim (Jane Doe No. 1) |
Plaintiff in 'Jane Doe No. 1 and Jane Doe No. 2 vs. the United States of America'; claims federal non-prosecution agr...
|
| Jane Doe No. 2 | Victim |
Plaintiff in federal lawsuit; declined to comment for the story.
|
| Alexander Acosta | Federal Prosecutor |
Accused of conspiring with Epstein's lawyers to circumvent public scrutiny; claimed he was pressured by Epstein's leg...
|
| Jay Lefkowitz | Epstein Attorney |
Corresponded with Acosta and Villafana; thanked Acosta for commitment to keep deal confidential.
|
| A. Marie Villafana | Lead Federal Prosecutor |
Acquiesced to Epstein's legal team's demands; suggested filing charges in Miami to avoid press.
|
| Edwards | Attorney (Victims) |
Represents Wild and Jane Doe No. 2; filed emergency motion to block non-prosecution agreement.
|
| Spencer Kuvin | Attorney |
Represented a 14-year-old victim labeled a prostitute.
|
| Alan Dershowitz | Epstein Attorney |
Harvard professor; part of Epstein's 'heavy-hitting' legal team.
|
| Jack Goldberger | Epstein Attorney |
Part of Epstein's legal team; did not respond to requests for comment.
|
| Roy Black | Epstein Attorney |
Part of Epstein's legal team.
|
| Guy Lewis | Epstein Attorney |
Former U.S. Attorney; part of Epstein's legal team.
|
| Gerald Lefcourt | Epstein Attorney |
Part of Epstein's legal team.
|
| Kenneth Starr | Epstein Attorney |
Former Whitewater special prosecutor; part of Epstein's legal team.
|
| Yasmin Vafa | Advocate |
Executive director of Rights4Girls; criticized the minimization of Epstein's crimes.
|
| Ric Bradshaw | Sheriff |
Palm Beach County Sheriff; allowed Epstein work release privileges; refused to answer questions.
|
| Cyrus Vance | District Attorney |
New York County District Attorney; his office argued on Epstein's behalf regarding sex offender status reduction.
|
| Ruth Pickholtz | Judge |
New York Supreme Court Judge; denied Epstein's petition to reduce sex offender status and expressed shock at the pros...
|
| Bill Clinton | Mentioned |
Mentioned in context of Kenneth Starr's investigation.
|
| Monica Lewinsky | Mentioned |
Mentioned in context of Kenneth Starr's investigation.
|
Timeline (4 events)
2007-10-12
2008-06-30
2011
Epstein petitioned to have his sex offender status reduced.
New York
Locations (5)
Relationships (4)
Described as 'unusual level of collaboration,' Acosta claimed he was 'unduly pressured' by the legal team.
Exchanged emails regarding minimizing press coverage for Epstein.
Bradshaw allowed Epstein work release privileges despite rules against it.
Vance's office argued on Epstein's behalf to reduce his sex offender status in NY.
Key Quotes (6)
"You beat yourself up mentally and physically... For me, it is the word 'pure' because he called me 'pure' in that room and then I remember what he did to me in that room."Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023049.jpg
Quote #1
"As soon as that deal was signed, they silenced my voice and the voices of all of Jeffrey Epstein's other victims."Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023049.jpg
Quote #2
"The conspiracy between the government and Epstein was really 'let's figure out a way to make the whole thing go away as quietly as possible,'"Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023049.jpg
Quote #3
"It's just outrageous how they minimized his crimes and devalued his victims by calling them prostitutes"Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023049.jpg
Quote #4
"I have to tell you, I'm a little overwhelmed because I have never seen a prosecutor's office do anything like this."Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023049.jpg
Quote #5
"On an 'avoid the press' note ... I can file the charge in district court in Miami which will hopefully cut the press coverage significantly."Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023049.jpg
Quote #6
Full Extracted Text
Complete text extracted from the document (10,111 characters)
16 The Virgin Islands Daily News PERVERSION OF JUSTICE Wednesday, February 27, 2019
PERVERSION
CONTINUED FROM PAGE 14
CONTINUED FROM PAGE 14
60 of them are now scattered around the country and abroad. Eight of them agreed to be interviewed, on or off the record. Four of them were willing to speak on video.
The women are now mothers, wives, nurses, bartenders, Realtors, hairdressers and teachers. One is a Hollywood actress. Several have grappled with trauma, depression and addiction. Some have served time in prison.
A few did not survive. One young woman was found dead last year in a rundown motel in West Palm Beach. She overdosed on heroin and left behind a young son.
As part of Epstein's agreement, he was required to register as a sex offender, and pay restitution to the three dozen victims identified by the FBI. In many cases, the confidential financial settlements came only after Epstein's attorneys exposed every dark corner of their lives in a scorched-earth effort to portray the girls as gold diggers.
"You beat yourself up mentally and physically," said Jena-Lisa Jones, 30, who said Epstein molested her when she was 14. "You can't ever stop your thoughts. A word can trigger something. For me, it is the word 'pure' because he called me 'pure' in that room and then I remember what he did to me in that room."
Now, more than a decade later, two unrelated civil lawsuits arose.
A civil trial set for Dec. 4 in Palm Beach County state court, involves Epstein and Edwards, whom Epstein had accused of legal misdeeds in representing several victims.
The case would have been noteworthy because it would mark the first time that Epstein's victims would have their day in court, and several of them were scheduled to testify.
However, Epstein settled that case and publicly apologized to Edwards — but he did not apologize to any of his victims.
A second lawsuit, known as the federal Crime Victims' Rights suit, is still pending in South Florida after a decade of legal jousting. It seeks to invalidate the non-prosecution agreement in hopes of sending Epstein to federal prison.
Wild, who has never spoken publicly until now, is Jane Doe No. 1 in "Jane Doe No. 1 and Jane Doe No. 2 vs. the United States of America," a federal lawsuit that alleges Epstein's federal non-prosecution agreement was illegal.
Federal prosecutors, including Acosta, not only broke the law, the women contend in court documents, but they conspired with Epstein and his lawyers to circumvent public scrutiny and deceive his victims in violation of the Crime Victims' Rights Act.
The law assigns victims a series of rights, including the right of notice of any court proceedings and the opportunity to appear at sentencing.
"As soon as that deal was signed, they silenced my voice and the voices of all of Jeffrey Epstein's other victims," said Wild, now 31. "This case is about justice, not just for us, but for other victims who aren't Olympic stars or Hollywood stars."
In court papers, federal prosecutors have argued that they did not violate the Crime Victims' Rights Act because no federal charges were ever filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida, an argument that was later dismissed by the judge.
Despite substantial physical evidence and multiple witnesses backing up the girls' stories, the secret deal allowed Epstein to enter guilty pleas to two felony prostitution charges. Epstein admitted to committing only one offense against one underage girl, who was labeled a prostitute, even though she was 14, which is well under the age of consent — 18 in Florida.
"She was taken advantage of twice — first by Epstein, and then by the criminal justice system that labeled a 14-year-old girl as a prostitute," said Spencer Kuvin, the lawyer who represented the girl.
"It's just outrageous how they minimized his crimes and devalued his victims by calling them prostitutes," said Yasmin Vafa, a human rights attorney and executive director of Rights4Girls, which is working to end the sexual exploitation of girls and young women.
"There is no such thing as a child prostitute. Under federal law, it's called child sex trafficking — whether Epstein pimped them out to others or not. It's still a commercial sex act — and he could have been jailed for the rest of his life under federal law," she said.
It would be easy to dismiss the Epstein case as another example of how there are two systems of justice in America, one for the rich and one for the poor. But a thorough analysis of the case tells a far more troubling story.
Unusual level of collaboration
A close look at the trove of letters and emails contained in court records provides a window into the plea negotiations, revealing an unusual level of collaboration between federal prosecutors and Epstein's legal team that even government lawyers, in recent court documents, admitted was unorthodox.
Acosta, in 2011, would explain that he was unduly pressured by Epstein's heavy-hitting lawyers — Lefkowitz, Harvard professor Alan Dershowitz, Jack Goldberger, Roy Black, former U.S. Attorney Guy Lewis, Gerald Lefcourt, and Kenneth Starr, the former Whitewater special prosecutor who investigated Bill Clinton's sexual liaisons with Monica Lewinsky.
That included keeping the deal from Epstein's victims, emails show.
"Thank you for the commitment you made to me during our Oct. 12 meeting," Lefkowitz wrote in a letter to Acosta after their breakfast meeting in West Palm Beach. He added that he was hopeful that Acosta would abide by a promise to keep the deal confidential.
"You ... assured me that your office would not ... contact any of the identified individuals, potential witnesses or potential civil claimants and the respective counsel in this matter," Lefkowitz wrote.
In email after email, Acosta and the lead federal prosecutor, A. Marie Villafana, acquiesced to Epstein's legal team's demands, which often focused on ways to limit the scandal by shutting out his victims and the media, including suggesting that the charges be filed in Miami, instead of Palm Beach, where Epstein's victims lived.
"On an 'avoid the press' note ... I can file the charge in district court in Miami which will hopefully cut the press coverage significantly. Do you want to check that out?" Villafana wrote to Lefkowitz in a September 2007 email.
Federal prosecutors identified 36 underage victims, but none of those victims appeared at his sentencing on June 30, 2008, in state court in Palm Beach County.
Most of them heard about it on the news — and even then they didn't understand what had happened to the federal probe that they'd been assured was ongoing.
Edwards filed an emergency motion in federal court to block the non-prosecution agreement, but by the time the agreement was unsealed — over a year later — Epstein had already served his sentence and been released from jail.
"The conspiracy between the government and Epstein was really 'let's figure out a way to make the whole thing go away as quietly as possible,'" said Edwards, who represents Wild and Jane Doe No. 2, who declined to comment for this story. "In never consulting with the victims, and keeping it secret, it showed that someone with money can buy his way out of anything."
VIP treatment
It was far from the last time Epstein would receive VIP handling.
Unlike other convicted sex offenders, Epstein didn't face the kind of rough justice that child sex offenders do in Florida state prisons. Instead of being sent to state prison, Epstein was housed in a private wing of the Palm Beach County jail.
Rather than having him sit in a cell most of the day, the Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office allowed Epstein work release privileges, which enabled him to leave the jail six days a week, for 12 hours a day, to go to a comfortable office that Epstein had set up in West Palm Beach.
This was granted despite explicit sheriff's department rules stating that sex offenders don't qualify for work release.
The sheriff, Ric Bradshaw, would not answer questions, submitted by the Miami Herald, about Epstein's work release.
Neither Epstein nor his lead attorney, Jack Goldberger, responded to multiple requests for comment for this story. During depositions taken as part of two dozen lawsuits filed against him by his victims, Epstein has invoked his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination, in one instance doing so more than 200 times.
In the past, his lawyers have said that the girls lied about their ages, that their stories were exaggerated or untrue and that they were unreliable witnesses prone to drug use.
In 2011, Epstein petitioned to have his sex offender status reduced in New York, where he has a home and is required to register every 90 days. In New York, he is classified as a level 3 offender — the highest safety risk because of his likelihood to re-offend.
A prosecutor under New York County District Attorney Cyrus Vance argued on Epstein's behalf, telling New York Supreme Court Judge Ruth Pickholtz that the Florida case never led to an indictment and that his underage victims failed to cooperate in the case.
However, Pickholtz denied the petition, expressing astonishment that a New York prosecutor would make such a request on behalf of a serial sex offender accused of molesting so many girls.
"I have to tell you, I'm a little overwhelmed because I have never seen a prosecutor's office do anything like this. I have done so many [sex offender registration hearings] much less troubling than this one where the [prosecutor] would never make a downward argument like this," she said.
Coming tomorrow: The victims' stories
[Photo Caption:] Jeffrey Epstein, second from left, in custody in West Palm Beach, Fla., in 2008. File photo by ASSOCIATED PRESS
[Pull Quote:] "You beat yourself up mentally and physically. You can't ever stop your thoughts. A word can trigger something. For me, it is the word 'pure' because he called me 'pure' in that room and then I remember what he did to me in that room." — Jena-Lisa Jones, who said Epstein molested her when she was 14
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023049
Discussion 0
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document